Hey Ben,
I live and fish in and around the SR.I could list a bunch of dives,and a bunch of lodges.It all depends on what you are looking for.My choice would be The Victorian in Altmar.Nice B and B.Been in it a bunch of times and is well maintained.Owned and Operated by Bob and Cindy Lockwood @ 845-279-4299.The resident guide is Walt Geryk.Mostly spey but does a lot of single fly.You can check out his site @
Fly & Spey Fish New York & Massachusetts: Steelhead, Trout and Salmon Fishing Guides.
Good Luck and yet me know what you think.
Scott