Last night I did the blind tasting with Bulleit and Buffalo Trace.
First off, I have to say I love the Bulleit bottle (old west elixir bottle from a medicine show).
Both had a good color.
Bulleit had a deeper fragrance, which I found interesting because the flavors were remarkably similar to me.
I would give a slight edge to Bulleit. I've had better bourbons, but they've all been quite a bit more expensive.
Bottom line: I could enjoy either one sitting around a campfire telling lies about the day's fishing.