The North American Fly Fishing Forum

The North American Fly Fishing Forum (http://www.theflyfishingforum.com/forums/)
-   Flies (http://www.theflyfishingforum.com/forums/flies/)
-   -   Tubes Love em or hate em (http://www.theflyfishingforum.com/forums/flies/289544-tubes-love-em-hate-em.html)

hooked1 06-23-2012 10:21 PM

Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Hey All,

Just looking to see if its just me or do others dislike the looks of the tube fly.I am far from a master but I do tie all my own flies.I have seen many great tiers dabble in to tubes.To me it is just not a fly.The profile sucks to the eye.There is no doubt that they produce.Its just not a very pleasing look to me.Nothing seems to flow.No sexy curve.Very blocky.Giant heads.For years it was all about small heads,and still is on most any fly.If you where to ask me I would call it a lazy-mans fly .I have never seen one that looks like a challenge.

Just my 2 cent

Scott

fishingfly 06-23-2012 11:48 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Depends on what you are fishing for. I think they add some nice versatility to a fly box. Fly Tier magazine had a special on them and of course I have to give it a shot. They showed different ways of rigging it other that the traditional stringer. For example a minnow pattern tied to the line free running through a floating grass tube fly has what seems to be an incredible action. Makes it look like the baitfish is nibbling on the grass. Keep in mind that I am primarily a bass fisherman though, I dont know if I would use it as much for trout.

gatortransplant 06-23-2012 11:53 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
While I havent fished many tube flies and have yet to tie one, some tube flies a la Greg Senyo and others are right on the cusp of looking like a classic salmon fly tied in the round. Since beauty is certainly in the eye of the beholder, why not try tying some tubes that look good to you? No reason you couldn't take a classic style fly that would usually be tied on a 6x or longer hook and tie it on a tube! Then you get all the benefits of a tube and the beauty o the classic!

kayo 06-23-2012 11:55 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Ever fished steelhead? got to love them. ;)

fredaevans 06-24-2012 09:14 AM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gatortransplant (Post 466886)
While I havent fished many tube flies and have yet to tie one, some tube flies a la Greg Senyo and others are right on the cusp of looking like a classic salmon fly tied in the round. Since beauty is certainly in the eye of the beholder, why not try tying some tubes that look good to you? No reason you couldn't take a classic style fly that would usually be tied on a 6x or longer hook and tie it on a tube! Then you get all the benefits of a tube and the beauty o the classic!

Gator 'nailed it' with his "tied in the round" comment. That's the deal with tubes, they look the same no matter how rotated (usually). Personally I'm not a 'tube fan' but many, many of the river fishermen here in the PNW swear by them for Salmon and Steelhead fishing.

hooked1 06-24-2012 12:07 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Kayo,steel is mostly what I fish.I am not saying that they are not effective.I have many friends that fish them.I just choose not to tie them.They just dont look like I would be satisfied with the outcome.Maybe its just me?Personal preference I guess .

Scott

gatortransplant 06-24-2012 12:58 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Now I want to see someone tie a Jock O Dee or something similar on a tube. I don't see why you couldn't tie a standard style on a tube?

Hardyreels 06-24-2012 02:22 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Hi Scott,

I never made any of them and have not used them either. I guess that's because I've got way too many traditional flies to spend time wondering what I should try next. I've fished with a fellow who uses them and they look good when they are traveling through the water.

Ard

jaybo41 06-24-2012 02:49 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gatortransplant (Post 466973)
Now I want to see someone tie a Jock O Dee or something similar on a tube. I don't see why you couldn't tie a standard style on a tube?

My vote goes to Ard to give this a shot! I have no doubt he could make a pretty looking Jock O Dee! :thumbsup:

I have fished with them on one occasion and they were productive. As such I have been tying them as of late. Something to break the monotony of 14-18 trout flies. For two handed rods, they seem to be ideal for fishing them on the swing, that's what I intend to do with mine. I'm not sure that I'd tie an Elk Hair Caddis on one but for the non traditional/classic streamers, they are IMHO, ideal.

I've tied some Intruder style flies on standard basic streamer hook, breaking the hook off and adding a stinger and on the tube. I'd have to say the tubes are easier to produce. They're not for everyone, but it's hard to argue with the productivity factor. Many, many fishermen & women more talented than me fish with them for a reason. There are also some incredible tyers out there who make a tube look pretty darn good if you ask me. What's more important than the look though is what the fish think of them.

BTW, the Wooly Bugger doesn't have much of a varying degree of side profile, yet is a highly effective pattern. They look pretty darn good on a tube if you ask me.

Net result, depending on what you fish for, I think they have their place for certain patterns. Other patterns I'll stick with the traditional stuff.

Still not convinced to give them a look? Take a look at this action.



Hardyreels 06-24-2012 03:05 PM

Re: Tubes Love em or hate em
 
Thanks Jaybo, you're a good fella :)

The images are hard to argue; the fly in that video looks great. I can only hope that any of mine look like that to a fish! A fellow sent me an Intruder that he tied with the hook trailing behind on a short tether. The fly is so nice I don't want to risk loosing it to some unseen snag in water too deep for me to go after it but I will use it. I would like to learn to make them as well as the one Jack sent me as a gift but it will require that I get a whole new lineup of materials. My other alternative is to ask Jack if he will do a swap with me for my traditional ties and if I had a dozen of his I would probably fish them alot.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:23 AM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2014, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Search Engine Optimization by vBSEO 3.6.0
2005-2014 The North American Fly Fishing Forum. All rights reserved.