Have you ever noticed that when you have a little extra time on your hands and you have a bunch of materials spread out on your tying table, the fly that you happen to be tying tends to "evolve" as you tie it?
Sometimes it's just a nuance change, the size of the hackle, the thinness or thickness of the dubbing, etc. But, sometimes its more fundamental and you end up with something that's only related to the fly that you wanted to tie when you first sat down. Case in point.
I convinced myself that I "needed" some olive scud-like nymphs to fish a section of the Tobyhanna Creek that runs through a meadow. The weeds march right down into the water in this section and I've seen what I think are trout nosing out scuds from the weeds by bulling their way along the creek bank. So, if the fish are rutting out scuds, then why not be a nice guy and accommodate them, save them some energy and at the same time, perhaps, get one or two to my landing net.
I warn you, these are not pretty ties, but sometimes evolution isn't pretty; it's the idea that's moving. From my standpoint, there's plenty of time to polish things off if something good comes out of what's evolving.
So, here's the fly that I needed. A #16 scud hook weighted with 7 turns of .010 lead wire, caddis green superfine dubbing and a small copper rib. Nothing special, but just what I needed:
But, what about a bead? Most fly fishermen that I know would take a beadhead anything over the same pattern without a bead. So, add one 2mm copper bead; works with the ribbing, too:
That works. I'd probably take the beadhead version myself. I guess I needed that add.
Now, I fish mostly in the Poconos, which are the same mountains as the Catskills; just in PA instead of NY. Not surprisingly, there's a lot of Catskill tying influence around here and one of those influences is hackling. Most of the flies that you'll see here in the Spring are going to have some form of collar hackle on them. So, since there's a natural brown hen hackle sitting just to my right; time for a collar hackle on this pattern:
And, if a collar hackle would work, then why not have a look at the fly fully hackled with a palmered brown feather? Why not? OK, here it is:
So, 4 evolution steps from a ribbed scud to a pseudo-woolly worm on a scud hook.
I never did get fishing today; that will have to wait until next weekend when I test this evolution on that piece of water.
Anyone else ever had a similar experience?