I have several non-ceramic bobbins that have served me fairly well over the past year or so, but I've developed a burr in one of them and it's cutting my line. Does anyone know of a good way to repair a burr inside the tube or is it not worth my time and should I just go buy a new bobbin. I'd like to save the $15 if I could (or maybe just get another one but either way it's not the end of the world!
In my early days of tying, I had that happen to several bobbins. IMO, unless you're a machinist or in some other profession where you have free access to the required tools, and can make those repairs, it would likely cost more than the new bobbin to try to repair the old one, particularly if you need someone else to do it.
I now only buy the ceramic type, specifically those made by Griffin, and have never had a problem with them. I've got about a dozen of them now of various types.
Spend the money & get the better bobbin, it will be worth it in the long run if you do a lot of tying.
flytire, that's really cool! I can honestly say I've never seen that before.
How can you be sure that the seed bead is smooth enough on the inside, not to cause the same problem that you're attempting to repair? I've seen plenty of beads that were cracked or deformed. Is there a certain quality you would need?
Not arguing with the repair, just asking!
The Griffin ceramic bobbins have what I'm assuming (yes, I know!) are inserts of much higher quality than a seed bead. I was thinking more in terms of expanding the old tube & adding the ceramic insert, although as you've shown, I would think a ceramic insert with the shrink tubing would work fine if you could get the inserts.
i cannot predict or assure anyone that a seed bead is not going to have a crack as well as i cannot predict or assure anyone that buys a ceramic tipped or ceramic tube bobbin holder also wont be cracked. i have absolutely no control of what comes out of the company that makes them.
i also cannot predict or assure anyone of the quality of all other fly tying tools. some tyers have used metal tube bobbin holders for decades without a single problem. i also cannot predict or assure anyone of the quality between a $2.95 bobbin holder vs a $19.95 bobbin holder with metal tubes.
if it were me, i would delegate any problematic bobbin holder to the waste bin or start using it to hold various types of wire (lead, lead free, copper etc). then i'd search the different bobbin holder manufacturers for the least expensive ceramic tipped ones and replace all of my metal tube bobbin holders or bite the bullet and get the ceramic tube bobbin holders (tiemco).
i'm not trying to be argumentative here.
i supplied a simple solution to a common problem that over time can/will occur with some metal tube bobbin holders. as i pointed out above, there are solutions to the problem and in a price range to suit everyone's wallet.
No argument here either! Excellent solution too & certainly inexpensive!
We're both thinking in the same terms, buy the better tool.
My question was only stemming from experience with beads that were not very good quality. I figured you might have a better handle on a particular brand or supplier.
I'm sure they vary a great deal.
Some of my older bobbins were damaged so badly that they didn't even work well for wire, at least not lead wire. I don't even use a bobbin for wire now.
When I tying commercially, I got into the habit of measuring & cutting the lead wire into lengths so I could duplicate the added weight each time I tied a particular pattern, and I kept notes about each pattern.
I gave the Tiemco ceramic tube bobbins a try, but didn't like them. Personal preference, nothing more. All the ones I use now are Griffin with the insert in the tube. A lot of the tying I do is with the Griffin Rod Wrapping bobbin, which is made to hold a 1 oz spool, and Danville Flat Nylon, my favorite tying thread, is available in 1 oz spools.
Most or today's bobbin holders will accommodate a wide variety of material spools by simply adjusting the arms to it them. The only thread spool they don't fit is the old gudebrod skinny spools. The height of spools from different manufacturers doesn't vary the much if at all.
I think I still have some of those old plastic Gudebrod fly tying bobbins & slim spools of thread around here. I had forgotten about them until now that you've mentioned them!
The 1oz spools are about twice the width of standard spools, and that bobbin is made for the larger spools popular with rod builders.
I broke a Griffin standard bobbin one time trying to pry the arms open enough to fit the 1 oz spools. The arm broke right at that little brass band, where they solder the whole thing together. That's when I went to the rod wrapping bobbins.