View Single Post
Old 07-18-2013, 12:19 PM
ZachMatthews ZachMatthews is offline
Join Date: Jul 2007
Location: Atlanta, Georgia
Posts: 21
ZachMatthews will become famous soon enoughZachMatthews will become famous soon enough
Default Re: 8wt or 9wt spey for stripers?

Nick -

I can't speak to Massachusetts stripers (by the way are you talking about river fish or ocean fish?), but I may be able to give you some general principles.

I wrote about this in American Angler last year and I've re-printed that article on my site if you care to take a look:

Article: Spey Stripers

I have been pretty satisfied with my 13' 7 weight Scott T2h for stripers up to about 10 pounds. I'm using Scientific Anglers Mastery Skagit Extreme line with this rod; it's a monster weight forward, integrated (although you can cut it and add loops), with an integrated very fast sinking tip.

The disadvantage of that kind of rig for stripers is that we usually use much bulkier flies than the steelhead and salmon guys can get away with. Thus when trying to huck a 6" long Major Mullet it takes multiple repetitive roll casts to pull the fly up the column high enough to do your setup strokes and begin the Spey cast.

I more or less "solved" this problem (at least in my fishery down south) by fishing floating, but diving flies like the Wiggle Minnow and its ilk. The added advantage of the Wiggle Minnow is that it will wake on the swing, thus having action even in traditional Spey casts, which of course stripers like.

I am in complete agreement that the 8 weight and a shorter length would be better for overhead casting. You might also consider sizing on up - Loomis made or makes an eleven-foot eleven-weight specifically for surf casting which can execute both overhead and Spey casts. You might be outgunned for the fish you catch but you'll be more versatile for sure in the flies you can present.

Rods-wise, the TFO Deer Creek is on the cheaper, but softer side, with more of a traditional European Spey action. The Scott LS3 is a little bit more expensive but still affordable (as Spey rods go) and it has a much faster action.

Good luck!

Reply With Quote