PDA

View Full Version : Net Recommendation



ksigtuck
10-25-2009, 06:12 PM
Hey guys I have finally narrowed down what type of net I want to pick up. I want to get one of the Brodin Ghost series nets but am not sure which model would be best. I am sure that some of you have these nets so please tell me which model you think would work the best for stream, creek and river trout fishing.
Thanks,
Tuck

MoscaPescador
10-26-2009, 01:09 AM
Hey guys I have finally narrowed down what type of net I want to pick up. I want to get one of the Brodin Ghost series nets but am not sure which model would be best. I am sure that some of you have these nets so please tell me which model you think would work the best for stream, creak and river trout fishing.
Thanks,
Tuck

I like the catch and release styles: Gallatin and the Firehole. The Gallatin is the larger of the two. If you are catching a wide range of sizes of trout, go with the Gallatin. If you are catching "shakers," get the Firehole.

MP

deon
10-26-2009, 01:36 PM
very interseting

fyshstykr
10-27-2009, 12:12 AM
As long as you get one with rubber mesh I say get whatever feels and looks right. Rubber is the way to go!!

Fly2Fish
10-27-2009, 03:04 PM
As long as you get one with rubber mesh I say get whatever feels and looks right. Rubber is the way to go!!

. . . as long as the "rubber" is that clear (or at least translucent) PVC that Brolin sells, and whose replacement nets fit a wide range of other brands such as my unusual Norwegian triangular collapsible extendable net. Previously I replaced the netting with a black rubber replacement net from Cabela's, and although it fit fine, it weighed a ton - easily several times heavier than the just-as-fish-friendly Brolin ghost netting.

fyshstykr
10-27-2009, 06:53 PM
That's a good point, the black netting is heavier. Right now the only rubber mesh net we have is the boat net which is black. I need to replace my other net someday, but I just don't use it very often anymore, so I'm in no rush. lol.

Fly2Fish
10-27-2009, 07:47 PM
Yeah, Fysh, weight for a boat net wouldn't be all that critical, but if your net is for wading like in my case, that's another matter. When I had replaced my original so-called fish-friendly knotless nylon (or whatever) netting with the black rubber replacement netting I got from Cabelas, I couldn't believe how much heavier the black rubber was. It got to the point when I had the net extended out maximum for netting my trout, it was really cumbersome with a big trout in it. It's tricky enough doing your own netting without having to deal with the extra weight.

One really nice characteristic that the translucent PVC Brolin netting shares with the black rubber is that there's no more confounded untangling of dropper rigs, since the hooks don't snag in the netting like happens with regular nets.

One interesting thing I noticed immediately when using the translucent Brolin PVC netting over the black rubber netting is that trout get a lot less spooked when they first see the net - again, something that makes it a lot easier netting your own trout. I guess that's why Brolin calls it a "ghost" net.

ksigtuck
10-27-2009, 09:30 PM
Thanks for the replies guys. I would like to get my hands on a couple of the models to see how they felt but unfortunately the only place around here that sells them only had one model in stock and I can't remember which it was. From the pictures on the Brodin website so many of the nets looked very similar in size but I want to here first hand experience so I don't end up ordering one only to find out that it is a lot bigger than what I needed it for and difficult to carry/use.
THanks for the help,
Tuck

ksigtuck
12-12-2009, 11:15 PM
Just a follow up...I picked up a Brodin Gallatin the other day. I haven't had a chance to get out on the water with it yet but am looking forward to giving it a try.
Tuck

tonysav
01-17-2010, 09:30 AM
I agree good choice.

michaeln
01-17-2010, 07:39 PM
I have a brodin ghost that I got for float tubing. It's OK, but now that I am fishing from a pram I wanted one with a longer handle.

I bought a large extendable handle Measure Net, and I like it MUCH more than the Brodin. It's light, the workmanship is better, it floats, the handle is long enough and it measures the fish for me. I got the rubber net option for it.

Brodins are WAY overpriced for the quality you get, IMO.

Frank Whiton
01-18-2010, 02:46 PM
Hi Everyone,

My Brodin net is of very high quality and well worth the money I paid for mine. The Measure Net is also a good net and many will like them.

Frank