This field test was timely indeed. As you all know over the past months we have had several threads that were focused on the banning of felt soled wading boots and the shift to Vibram rubber soles. This 'shift' in and of itself has left many folks concerned about not only traction issues when fly fishing but even personal safety as well. In an unsolicited twist of fate I was ask by the good people at 'Grip Studs' a division of Deardorff Fitzsimmons Corporation, Merlin OR. to test their new stud product.
I had very recently purchased a new pair of Simms Rivershed boots and with them the Simms Hard Bite Star Cleat and had not yet installed the product to the boots. When I was alerted of this opportunity to test the 'Grip Studs' product I decided to hold off on installing the Simms cleats. Once I got the package from Grip Studs, I elected to install a set of each; one on the left boot and the other product on the right. This was I figured a true side by side field test.
First thing you will notice is the unique thread design and the cool little lug tool supplied with the Grip Studs. The Simms product is applied using Phillips head screws and your own sharp pointed screw driver.
Before ever taking a step into a stream or river I had to install the two different types of cleats. The first thing I / you, notice is that the Grip Stud cleat snaps smartly into the lug tool and there is very little chance of either failed insertions or dropped studs. Also there is no fear of a minor stab wound as there always is when applying pressure to a Phillips head screw with a driver. This was a + 10 for me on the Grip Stud product.
A stud snapped onto the tool ready for insertion;
With either product a fair level of force is needed to properly insert the studs / cleat screws but during the work I dropped several screws when they popped sideways under the force on the screw driver. No slips occurred with the Grip Stud insertion. I used an identical pattern on both boot soles and then I took them fishing.
Field / stream observations were as follows: Due to the fact that the Grip Studs protrude a bit farther above the Vibram rubber they seemed to grip better. I rated this difference at about 25 - 30% better especially on mossy surfaces. While the Simms cleats held well I could get them to shift and slip somewhat easier than I could do the same with the Grip Stud foot under equal pressure. I photographed the studs / cleats at an angle perpendicular with their position in the boot soles to demonstrate this height difference.
The simms Star Cleat;notice that it sits almost flush with the surrounding rubber cleats around it.
The Grip Stud; You can see the stud protruding above the rubber cleats and depending on the surfaces you encounter this additional height can mean a better bite.
Will this height result in more or quicker wear? I can not answer that after only a couple weeks but will report back at seasons end on this issue. In truth, we are talking about traction and safety here not how long a set of studs will last. Based on prior experience with carbide steel studs I would expect to get several years service from a pair of these. Of course if you hike them along the sides of asphalt roadways they will wear quicker I presume.
This shows wear after a couple weeks of fishing. I did not hike the studs / cleats.
All scores are tens huh? I have been using rubber soled boots since I first discovered their availability. I've had the interchangeable sole type, the solid Vibram type and have trusted my safety and that of my tackle to steel cleats on the boot soles. This product is as good as any traction device I've ever had on a wading boot and because they can be replaced if and when they wear down, better than most I've ever waded with. If you are having to buy new wading boots either to comply with regulations or because yours are worn out I suggest the Grip Studs product as your grip on the stream bed.
So we reach the bottom line............. Pricing:
Grip Stud 20 stud kit with insertion tool = $39.49
The Simms 16 cleat product retails at $39.95
For my money I like the Grip Studs, when you run the numbers 20 studs vs. 16 cleats, and a very safe tool to use for insertian the gulf widens a little more.
Ard
Suggested use pattern;
I had very recently purchased a new pair of Simms Rivershed boots and with them the Simms Hard Bite Star Cleat and had not yet installed the product to the boots. When I was alerted of this opportunity to test the 'Grip Studs' product I decided to hold off on installing the Simms cleats. Once I got the package from Grip Studs, I elected to install a set of each; one on the left boot and the other product on the right. This was I figured a true side by side field test.
First thing you will notice is the unique thread design and the cool little lug tool supplied with the Grip Studs. The Simms product is applied using Phillips head screws and your own sharp pointed screw driver.
Before ever taking a step into a stream or river I had to install the two different types of cleats. The first thing I / you, notice is that the Grip Stud cleat snaps smartly into the lug tool and there is very little chance of either failed insertions or dropped studs. Also there is no fear of a minor stab wound as there always is when applying pressure to a Phillips head screw with a driver. This was a + 10 for me on the Grip Stud product.
A stud snapped onto the tool ready for insertion;
With either product a fair level of force is needed to properly insert the studs / cleat screws but during the work I dropped several screws when they popped sideways under the force on the screw driver. No slips occurred with the Grip Stud insertion. I used an identical pattern on both boot soles and then I took them fishing.
Field / stream observations were as follows: Due to the fact that the Grip Studs protrude a bit farther above the Vibram rubber they seemed to grip better. I rated this difference at about 25 - 30% better especially on mossy surfaces. While the Simms cleats held well I could get them to shift and slip somewhat easier than I could do the same with the Grip Stud foot under equal pressure. I photographed the studs / cleats at an angle perpendicular with their position in the boot soles to demonstrate this height difference.
The simms Star Cleat;notice that it sits almost flush with the surrounding rubber cleats around it.
The Grip Stud; You can see the stud protruding above the rubber cleats and depending on the surfaces you encounter this additional height can mean a better bite.
Will this height result in more or quicker wear? I can not answer that after only a couple weeks but will report back at seasons end on this issue. In truth, we are talking about traction and safety here not how long a set of studs will last. Based on prior experience with carbide steel studs I would expect to get several years service from a pair of these. Of course if you hike them along the sides of asphalt roadways they will wear quicker I presume.
This shows wear after a couple weeks of fishing. I did not hike the studs / cleats.
All scores are tens huh? I have been using rubber soled boots since I first discovered their availability. I've had the interchangeable sole type, the solid Vibram type and have trusted my safety and that of my tackle to steel cleats on the boot soles. This product is as good as any traction device I've ever had on a wading boot and because they can be replaced if and when they wear down, better than most I've ever waded with. If you are having to buy new wading boots either to comply with regulations or because yours are worn out I suggest the Grip Studs product as your grip on the stream bed.
So we reach the bottom line............. Pricing:
Grip Stud 20 stud kit with insertion tool = $39.49
The Simms 16 cleat product retails at $39.95
For my money I like the Grip Studs, when you run the numbers 20 studs vs. 16 cleats, and a very safe tool to use for insertian the gulf widens a little more.
Ard
Suggested use pattern;
