The best non-fiction fishing literature you've read

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
I've been a big fan of Gary LaFontaine's work for quite a while. I can't remember which book I read first or how exactly I stumbled upon it. I think it was Caddisflies and I found it in the Missoula Public Library the first year I lived here. I was a greenhorn fly fisherman, new to the West and the Big Waters, and hungry - starving - for knowledge. For anything to teach me all that I was missing. I was a self taught trout fisherman from the start, learned on a couple little put and take streams of middle Michigan. So books had always been my guide and experience my teacher.

I read The Dry Fly not long after. I can actually remember the apartment I lived in while reading that book for the first time, it was utterly amazing to me that someone could know so much about fishing and be such a good writer, the romanticism was heighten by the fact that Gary had lived and fished the waters I so dearly wanted to learn about. That book taught me a lot and changed the way I approached angling for trout with flies.

Now, 12 or so year later, a couple weeks ago I grabbed the same old hardcover copy from the same shelf. My life so different now, my 3 year old daughter had already picked out her books and was trying to be patient while dad looked for something. I always head to the 799 section and just scan...as her patience ran out, I thought - "what the hell, I might as well read it again" and home I went with The Dry Fly again.

I remember how interesting and intimidating the book was a dozen years ago. Some of it is still intimidating, just in scope now, but it is mostly enlightening. I appreciate his approach and style so much more now. The life long dedication to his quarry. Gary was a true innovator, a scientist and a dreamer. It's a damn shame he left so young. I wish I could have met him. There are plenty of people still around that fished with him that I consider seeking out.

Since this is getting longer than I initially intended and I haven't yet begun to get into the book, I think I'll change my tack. I've made it clear that this book is important to me, and I wonder if anyone else has read it and feels similarly.

And finally, please share the books and writers that have changed and/or shaped your life as a fly angler.
 

wannafish

Well-known member
Messages
702
Reaction score
24
Location
New Brunswick, Canada
I'll have to read that book this winter; I've really only read one flyfishing book having just seriously fished a couple years now. My wife bought it for me last Christmas and I probably read it 3 times at least; "The Fly And the Fish" by John Atherton who also died young btw. The book was written in the late 40's I believe so there's some out dated stuff about making lines but riveting stories and anecdotes of fishing all over N.A. for trout and salmon/steelhead, as well as fishing and tying techniques. Lee Wulff was one of his fishing partners. A really good read.
 
Last edited:

fire instructor

Well-known member
Messages
732
Reaction score
8
Location
Upstate NY (Albany Area)
As a newbie, I'm sure that my fly-fishing library is a mere smidgen of what many of you have (only four books, a few magazines, and a DVD, at this point), but I'm thoroughly enjoying the solid explanations and the accompanying clear, detailed, photos of process in Charlie Craven's Basic Fly Tying.

In fact, I went to the local fly shop last night, and spent $50 on materials to start to read and tie instead of just reading!
 

ausablebrown

Well-known member
Messages
840
Reaction score
19
Location
Ohio
I havn't read that one yet Dean, but it is on my list. I'm headed back to Yellowstone again next summer so I just picked up Craig Matthews book on Yellowstone. My favorite to this point is Schweiberts "Matching the Hatch". It is absolutely loaded with information and he was also a decent writer himself. I particularly appreciate his anecdotal asides and specific information about eastern waters. He spent more time fishing MI and New England than I have spent daydreaming about it. I've also picked up a couple of his other books that are collections of short stories; nonfiction but not so much informational as they are pleasure reading.
 

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
Wannafish - I heard of that title but never read it, I have read a little by Wulff, another one of my fisherman heroes. f you have a library nearby see what they have, there are so many fishing books not all will suite you. I usually try to read some of a book before deciding to add it to my library. I ordered Dry Fly last week for permanent addition to mine. Now is the best time to brush up on your reading! A good introduction to LaFontaine's writing and thinking process is his first book - The Challenge of Trout.

Rick -- I've heard a lot of good things about Craven's tying instruction, good choice. I spent quite a bit of x-mas cash on materials this week, too! Have you checked out the excellent Nymph Tie-Along thread that Pococno has going right now?

---------- Post added at 07:47 AM ---------- Previous post was at 07:39 AM ----------

I havn't read that one yet Dean, but it is on my list. I'm headed back to Yellowstone again next summer so I just picked up Craig Matthews book on Yellowstone. My favorite to this point is Schweiberts "Matching the Hatch". It is absolutely loaded with information he was also a decent writer himself. I particularly appreciate his anecdotal asides and specific information about eastern waters. He spent more time fishing MI and New England than I have spent daydreaming about it.
Hi ausauble - I think you'd enjoy LaFontaine's anecdotes. You'd enjoy the story about a specific brown trout in the PM that they studied for a few days, and he thought the caddis hatch on the Muskegon was one of the best. He grew up in the East and knew those rivers, too. What I find so great about this book, and all of his writings, is that they are not geographically specific. He really wanted to crack some of the codes of trout, in general, and approached it very scientifically. Check it out, you'll never fish the same way.
 

fire instructor

Well-known member
Messages
732
Reaction score
8
Location
Upstate NY (Albany Area)
Have you checked out the excellent Nymph Tie-Along thread that Pococno has going right now?
I've been following the nymph tie-along, but I really haven't started tying yet, as I pick-up my magnifying light this wekend, while in NYC. Got a Carson MagniFly ($28 @ B&H Camera). With my eyesight, I'm lucky that I can see a 6/0 thread without a magnifier, no less tie anything with it! Sure sucks to get old, but I suppose that it beats the alternative! ;)
 

gt05254

Well-known member
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
123
Location
Bennington, VT
Probably the most inspirational book I own, especially from a tying standpoint:
[/IMG]

I'm fortunate to count many friends and acquaintances involved in producing the book, as well as having their flies in it.

This is one of the two coolest artifacts (IMHO) at the American Museum of Fly Fishing: a box of antique Jock Scott's. It was fun to have it under my care for almost 7 years:



I leaf through this book and just want to start tying. Or better still, go salmon fishing!
Gary
 

fredaevans

Well-known member
Messages
11,186
Reaction score
126
Location
White City (tad north of Medford) Oar-E-Gone
Three books immediately come to mind, all classic or if you will "Gold Standards."

Trey Combs "Steelhead Fly Fishing and Flies" first published in 1976. Many 'how to's written after this, but this is still the Steelhead fly flickers 'Bible.'

Hugh Falkus's "Speycasting, A new Technique" published in 1994. If you were into 2-hander casting this was the book you hunted down for 'self-teaching.' And unless you lived in Darkest British Columbia or the UK ... this was probably where you started.

My third call would be:

"Ted Leeson/Jim Schollmeyer's "The Fly Tier's Benchside Reference to Techniques and Dressing Styles." (First published in 1998) 400 pages of pure magic for fly tiers of all skill levels. If there's 6 ways to achieve a desired result, they'll cover all six. Clearly written, informative AND all the pictures are in colour. That last bit may not sound like it would make much difference, but let me tell you ... it really does!

fae
 

mcnerney

Administrator
Messages
20,615
Reaction score
319
Location
Pinedale, WY
Dean: I have to agree, I love reading anything by Gary LaFontaine, excellent writer and the knowledge he had was just amazing. Pat Dorsey's books on fishing tailwaters are worth reading. Denny Rickards "Stillwater Presentation" is an excellent book for those of you that like stillwater fishing. Rene Harrop's book "Learning from the Water" is also an excellent read.
 

wt bash

Well-known member
Messages
1,983
Reaction score
38
Location
Akron Ohio (don't let that fool you)
While it might not the "best" but The Handbook of Hatches by Dave Hughes is a good read. Not to be overly cliche but anything by Gierach new and old, I gobble up. Another really good read is Brown Trout but I can't for the life of me remember who wrote it, I found it on my grandmothers bookshelf no less!
 

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
Rip - I've never read Marinaro, though I know I have to.

Gary and Fred, I am not an anadromous fish fisherman... but I trust you both. If I ever decide to take up that aspect of our pursuit, I'll look them up.

Larry, glad to hear someone else has read and appreciates LaFontaine's contribution to the sport. I'm not a stillwater fisherman nor much of a tailwater fisherman, just because neither are all that prevalent in close proximity. Though I would like to learn more about both, particularly tailwaters -- the Mo isn't that far! I'll write these names down. And thanks for the Harrop title, I'll look for that simply because his contribution to fly pattern innovation is so important.

wt bash -- I really enjoy Dave Hughes' writings, I recommend his books often. He is a very accessible and smart writer. Now please fine the author of this Brown Trout book your talking about...I've looked for good books that are specific to brown trout and never found anything. If you find it, please let me know. O, and Gierach isn't cliche, he is what he is and I've enjoyed plenty of his books, it's just not the kind of fishing lit I'm talking about here, stories vs. style and technique.
 

wt bash

Well-known member
Messages
1,983
Reaction score
38
Location
Akron Ohio (don't let that fool you)
It might have been the Compleat Brown Trout by Cecil E Heacox but the cover doesn't look the same and the print date seems to modern. I'll keep looking though, hopefully she may still have it. Over the river and through the woods.....
 

diamond rush

Well-known member
Messages
900
Reaction score
17
Location
Winston-Salem, NC
Disclaimer: I almost exclusively nymph, due to the water I fish on: narrow, deep spring creeks full of 8-12" brown trout.

Anyway, two books have really broadened my knowledge of nymphs: how to study them, how to tie them, and new techniques on how to fish them.

1) Nymph Fishing for Larger Trout by Charles Brooks. Don't let the title fool you. The author presents a comprehensive guide for fishing nymphs in all situations for trout of all sizes.

2) Nymphs by Ernest Schweibert. The author breaks down the major nymphs and other aquatic trout food found in the United States into their families, and provides anecdotes, color plates, and patterns for each, as well as describes their behaviors and habitats. Despite the reference nature of this text, I read it cover-to-cover and learned a great deal about the aquatic phases of the insects that inhabit a trout stream.
 

Rip Tide

Well-known member
Messages
11,146
Reaction score
3,505
Location
quiet corner, ct
Although Gary LaFontaine lived in Montana, he was originally from Connecticut and was a member of our club. In fact he first wrote about his experiments with trilobal yarn in our club newsletter. I think of him often as he died from ALS (Lou Gehrig's disease), a disease that I'm much too familiar with.
I met Dr.Schweibert once as well. I always thought that that his writing was a bit dry, that was until I experienced one of his slide shows. :rolleyes:
 

mcnerney

Administrator
Messages
20,615
Reaction score
319
Location
Pinedale, WY
Although Gary LaFontaine lived in Montana, he was originally from Connecticut and was a member of our club. In fact he first wrote about his experiments with trilobal yarn in our club newsletter. I think of him often as he died from ALS (Lou Gehrig's disease), a disease that I'm much too familiar with.
I met Dr.Schweibert once as well. I always thought that that his writing was a bit dry, that was until I experienced one of his slide shows. :rolleyes:
Wow, getting the chance to know both of those guys must have been quite the experience!

Diamond: I forgot about "Nymph Fishing for Larger Trout by Charles Brooks", yes, that is indeed a very good book!
 

gt05254

Well-known member
Messages
1,564
Reaction score
123
Location
Bennington, VT
I got to know Ernie very well over about a 7 year stretch, visited him at home several times. He laughed when I told him "Nymphs" got me through Aquatic Ecology at Cornell. Not trying to establish hero status here, just a note that he was an interesting guy, well-egoed, of course, but its hard to dispute (though many will) his status as one of - if not the most - influential fly fishing writers of his generation. I offer "Trout" as one example. He always used to use the AMFF booth as home base at the big fly fishing show in Somerset, NJ. It was fun to watch guys hover around out in the crowd, waiting for the opening to move in, hand extended, invariably saying, "You won't remember me, Dr. Schwiebert, but......fill in the blank." If I saw that once, I saw it a thousand times.

Did you know he wrote travel articles for airline magazines??

Gary
 

jk 8

Well-known member
Messages
69
Reaction score
4
Location
Chicago
Seems the trend here is non-fiction instructional books, but the books that have really set my attitude about fishing are those by John Gierach. I have read all his stories multiple times, and they never get old. As far as instructional books go, I havent read many of those, being from the age of the internet I got most of my information from websites like FAOL.
 
Top