Thanks Thanks:  0
Likes Likes:  0
Dislikes Dislikes:  0
Results 1 to 6 of 6

Thread: Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

  1. Default Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

    I just went to the lake I dock my boat at to take it out of the water today. It's not a fishing boat, it's a recreational boat. As I was bringing it over to the public launch to load it up on the trailer, I saw 5 or 6 guys shore fishing, and noticed more boats on the lake than I ever would have imagined in October. It hit me that they just stocked the lake on Friday with trout. As I brought the boat near the dock, I saw several fish jumping literally out of the water. Some looked like some good size trout. As many of you know, I am new to fly fishing, and I have pretty much fished for bass since I got it. Can anyone offer any suggestions on how I can catch these fish on my fly rod? What type of fly do I use? Nymph, Dry, Streamer? Looked like most of the people fishing were using live bait and bobber. I just assume slit my wrist than bobber fish. One older guy that I talked to briefly had some kind of crazy rig with a clear float and 3 flies dropped behind it on a spinning reel setup. He said he didn't have any luck today, but yesterday with the same rig he caught about 10-15 fish in 2 hours. The lake I refer to is Harvey's Lake in northeast PA.

  2. Default Re: Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

    Quote Originally Posted by Surfin the Susquehanna View Post
    Can anyone offer any suggestions on how I can catch these fish on my fly rod?
    Surfin... I would start with a wooly bugger in different colors, clear sinking fly line and and slow trolling. If you want to use your floating fly line, you could tie on a Royal Wulff dry fly and cast to the fish. If the fish are near the surface you could add a sinking tip and try retrieving a wooly bugger.

  3. Default Re: Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

    I have really only messed around with Bluegills in a smaller lake. Like I mentioned, most of my fly fishing has been in a river for bass. I want to learn the techniques to catch trout. I feel real good about where I am in skill level in river fishing for smallies. Oregon, I'll give your suggestions with the wooly buggers a try. I have several colors and many in the smaller size for trout. I also stopped by my local shop here and he sugested small caddis flys and he also gave me 2 streamers to try. He said his experience is they are either hit or miss. He said if they are active, these streamers will be lights out. We'll see, as I am going out Saturday morning. This is what it looks like.
    Attachment 379
    Attached Images Attached Images

  4. Default Re: Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

    surfin... Have fun and good luck. As you know, the only way to learn how to catch fish is to go fishing!

  5. Default Re: Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

    Rough Weekend..... Took the boat back up to the lake Saturday morning and went out with such high hopes. The fish were jumping everywhere. Funny thing is, I didn't see a bug in the air. Don't know what the heck these fish were jumping for. They were coming clear out of the water. I tried every dry fly in my box. I tried wooly buggers, those thing I posted above, I even got desperate and threw a bobber and a worm out there while I was still fly fishing. Not a nibble. I was in a boat for 5 hours and caught 1 bluegill.... compliments of the bobber and worm.

    I went back out to a stocked stream this morning(Sunday). I learned something today, I obviously need a lot of practice trout fishing. I fished from 8AM until 1 PM and caught 1 fish. My brother in law who I went with caught 3, using worms. I'll never tell him, but the fish I caught, I hooked him in the belly with a streamer, so apparently, I got lucky as hell and snagged him. Technically I got skunked. I started out with this thing.....
    Attachment 380

    Then I tried wooly buggers of all sorts. I hadn't tried a dry fly because there wasn't a bug in the air and I didn't see anything coming to the surface. I did try one once the sun came out, but nothing. I came across 5 other guys and they were not cathing anything either. 2 of them had fly setups as well.

    With my limited skill level, the only way I could fish the tight stream was to cast up stream with the dry flies and retrieve them back. I casted around downed trees, every rock I could find, into and around every deep pool I could find and nothing.

    I need some encouragment...LoL
    Attached Images Attached Images

  6. #6

    Default Re: Fall Lake Fishing for Trout

    Quote Originally Posted by Surfin the Susquehanna View Post
    Rough Weekend..... The fish were jumping everywhere. Funny thing is, I didn't see a bug in the air. Don't know what the heck these fish were jumping for. They were coming clear out of the water. ... I need some encouragment...LoL
    The fish were probably going for emergers. This time of year you have ~4 possibilities in our region: midges, tricos, very small blue winged olives, or if you get lucky, white mayflies. Warning: I haven't fished our region for nearly 2 weeks so my prediction of the mix could be off a tad or even well off the mark--I suspect the white mayflies are now completely gone as they were on the sharp decline the last evening that I fished. Given what you described I would start tossing a hopper/dropper rig with a small pheasant tail (#18 or less), a small midge (#20-24, brown/off-white or black/gray), or a soft hackle such as a soft-hackle pheasant tail or a partridge and brown or partridge and orange (#16-18). If you are comfortable throwing a 3 nymph rig use a strike indicator over all three (pheasant tail or soft-hackle pheasant tail, partridge & orange or brown, and midge). Keep the dropper short so as to keep your nymph(s) near the surface where the fish are obviously looking. On a hopper/dropper rig I'd put the first nymph no more than ~12-18" behind the hopper. Two weeks ago in our area a wet light Cahill (#16) would draw many hits from trout looking for the white mayfly emergers, but as I mentioned, I suspect that hatch has completely passed us now. Right after the recent trout stocking the fish were nailing pheasant tails trailed near the surface. I don't know if the trout saw the pheasant tail as an emerger or saw a brown blob reminiscent of Purina Aquamax 600 (trout pellet), but either way it worked quite well.

    The other option would be to pull a light colored streamer on or near the surface imitating a minnow chasing the emergers.

    Good luck to you.

Similar Threads

  1. Promises to Wife.
    By JBinUTAH in forum Fly Fishing Humor
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 09-19-2012, 01:33 PM
  2. Your best tip for saltwater fly fishing
    By BigCliff in forum Saltwater Fly Fishing
    Replies: 30
    Last Post: 01-18-2011, 02:27 AM
  3. My favorite bug photos so far this year
    By Troutnut in forum General Discussion
    Replies: 2
    Last Post: 05-04-2007, 10:33 AM
  4. Q about backing
    By tenetxnosce in forum General Discussion
    Replies: 10
    Last Post: 06-16-2006, 03:00 PM
  5. Which rod?
    By WDRookie in forum Fly Rods
    Replies: 11
    Last Post: 02-25-2005, 10:44 PM

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •