The North American Fly Fishing Forum

The North American Fly Fishing Forum (
-   General Discussion (
-   -   Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them? (

roofish 02-10-2013 01:01 PM

Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
What do you prefer when it comes to your fly boxes?

Ripple foam?
Wallets? Don't flies get stuck in the felt?
& any other's that you may have tried or come up with?

I have made my own but the foam seems to rip to easily.

Please help:)

fredaevans 02-10-2013 01:19 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
Great question; threads here about fly boxes but until you listed all the options it had never occured to me just how many choices there really are. Add to your list the Hardy line with the little flip lids.

Always thought they were the cutest things going until I tried to fish out a small fly .... :icon_roll Personal preference is fairly small regardless of the hook holder 'thingie.' Well, I will take a total pass on the 'slot' or 'nubby' hook holder type.

But on the water I'll just toss a small one or two in the wader or shirt pocket and be done with it. Candidly, I just don't loose that many flies so "Less Ismore" works for me.

rayzor 02-10-2013 01:44 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
C&F Waterproof I like the best, Tough !

wt bash 02-10-2013 01:49 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
I'm pretty cheap when it comes to boxes so I go with the good old fashion myran compartment boxes for dries and nymphs, for streamers any split foam box will do.

gt05254 02-10-2013 02:01 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
Oh, I don't know. Maybe Wheatley. Or maybe DeWitt. I dunno. Depends on the day, I guess (boy, have I gotten a log of mileage out of this pic or what?)

bigjim5589 02-10-2013 02:11 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
Roofish, as the years have gone by & I've accumulated more & more flies, I've obtained several different types of boxes. Used to be I stuck with the Plano type plastic boxes, and they work fine for some types of flies, but not as well for others. I've had some aluminum boxes, but have come to prefer plastic. Aluminum corrodes, while plastic does not. Plastic however cracks, so none are perfect. I'm also cheap, I can't see paying $20 or more for a fly box, when a similar one with a $6 -$8 price tag is available, particularly since some of the higher priced boxes appear to be identical to the less expensive versions.

IMO, a variety of sizes is a good idea if you tie or buy a variety of fly types & sizes. I've got flies of all shapes & sizes, and one size box doesn't fit all flies.

I like simple boxes too, waterproof is good, but not always a necessity. I have several boxes that have the slit, flat foam in them a few with ripple foam. All work fine IMO, and I understand none will last forever. I'm not going to last forever either, and expect most of the boxes will still outlast me.

Here's a few I have & like:
Plano, small size about 4"X7". Holds a good number of flies.

Fox Box, has molded plastic slots, seems to work better with heavier wire hooks, like those pictured. (saltwater)

Flambeau Double sided box. One side has ripple foam, the other is like the Plano box.

Large Plano, with carry handle. This is one of my boat boxes I like for big flies.
Not sure these are still made. I have two & they have slots that allow them to be attached together. Holds a lot of flies, even big ones!

Hinged & waterproof box. Got this one from an Ebay seller. Nice box IMO. has the pre slotted flat foam inserts.

Small pocket size Flambeau box. I've had this one for many years. Ripple foam insert, one sided. Only holds a few flies, but a good one to keep things light.

Large Flambeau polystyrene box. I bought several of these when I was tying commercially to use for selling flies of various sizes at shows. Not a box I would want to carry afield, as the plastic cracks too easily, but a good one for storage since the plastic is clear.

Large Plano, holds a lot of flies. Another good for storage, but not something I would want to carry.

codypom 02-10-2013 02:44 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
I see that you guys have a lot of flies not stuck in foam. What flies are ok to put into compartmented boxes and which ones need to be in foam?

dakotakid 02-10-2013 02:45 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
Don't forget fleece or shearling (fly wallets) and Press-to-seal folders or bags (Finsport wallets).

My preferences:
Haven't tried magnetic, but don't like rippled foam. I like slotted foam and plastic containers with secure latches and clear lids. As a result, I like Cabelas "double-sided fly box". Seem tough and reasonably waterproof.

Not sure who makes it for them, but other retailers also sell them with their logo stamped on them.

lightline 02-10-2013 03:07 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
I like foam. Flies stay put, and can't blow away when the box is opened. I can see each fly in the box clearly, by itself. I cut my own slots in ripple-foam boxes and space the slots based roughly on the size of flies I'm going to store in them. Prefer the magnetic closures, no latches/snaps to fuss with or break. And they float if dropped in the drink. They must fit in a shirt pocket (small/medium). I drill a hole on each side and run a piece of dacron though them so I can hang them from a necklace too. Each box filled by category: terrestrials/attractors/pmd's/caddis/certain river/etc. Mine happen to be Orvis. Not expensive either, much less than the popular pre-slotted foam boxes. For saltwater, I just use a slotted-foam Bugger Barn.

fredaevans 02-10-2013 03:20 PM

Re: Fly Box Frustrations, anyone have them?
Gentlemen, and Ladies, I think we have some SERIOUS needs for 'intervention.' "To protect and serve" intervention(s).

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:43 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.40 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
2005-2017 The North American Fly Fishing Forum. All rights reserved.