Best Overall Fly Vest

mikenewpal

Member
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
Just curious for all of you veteran fly fishers, as to what you prefer in a fly fishing vest? What brand at a reasonable cost that offers all the good things you would want in a vest?

Thanks, look forward to seeing the results.

Mike
 

Yoffione

Well-known member
Messages
91
Reaction score
0
Location
Jones, OK
I've gone through 3 vests, 2 Orvis and 1 Simms looking for my ideal setup. I have settled on a smaller Orvis chest pack, don't remember the name. I am able to carry 2 decent fly boxes that I customize for each outing depending on my needs, along with the mandatory tippet, leaders, split shot, floatant, strike indicators, thermometer, blah, blah, blah........... With the vests I got to where I carried way too much stuff. I have my tackle bag in the boat usually close by with more gear than 5 people could need.

For saltwater I carry a little JW Outfitters Bonefish pack with a good sized fly box, extra leader, tippet and a pair of pliers.
 

Joni

Well-known member
Messages
4,611
Reaction score
19
I am terrible. I have a Columbia vest (cloth) with zip on fleece sleeves, and a Mesh Columbia Vest. But I also have the Hydration backpack with the pockets on the front like a vest, and the fanny/chest pack combo from Orvis, and now I am using the Orvis sling. I guess I have every mood covered LOL
I wore the fanny pack when guiding because I could pack 4 System X boxes plus all other gear and two water bottles for clients. It would get a little heavy, plus wet if I had to wade deeper water, so I ended up hanging it on my shoulder, which promted the sling. I love this sling. Even got a loop for a net, that no matter where you slide the sling it stays in the back.
 

Fish Bones

Well-known member
Messages
3,564
Reaction score
3
Best new vest... William Joseph Fusion
Best value on a vest... Clear Creek Elkader Guide Vest
 

madriverbrown

Active member
Messages
29
Reaction score
0
I use a chest pack each time I go out. You can get them through Bass Pro , Cabelas and the like. Never cared for a vest but you can get a good vest at Bass Pro also.
 

ffffg

Well-known member
Messages
108
Reaction score
0
i wade deep all the time for some reason, up to my tip toes.. that gets the lower vest wet.. if you get your hooks wet and dont dry them out at days end theywill rust, so that puts leaders, floats, sinkers, and that type stuff on the bottim pockets.. the upper pockets that dont get wet hold the flys, and they must fit the fly boxes... so make sure the vest will hold the fly boxes you want to use. and that they fit where you want them... after a couple years, lots of them... they make waterproof fly boxes , but they are expensive. but can be very nice.. up to 40.00 dollars a pop.. dave..
 

Frank Whiton

Administrator
Messages
5,415
Reaction score
30
Location
Central Florida
Some of the Simm's vest are hard to beat. I use an Orvis compact chest pack most of the time. When I fish from my pontoon boat I have extra fly boxes in the pontoon packs. The chest pack is narrow enough that it doesn't interfer with rowing or casting. It carries my tools, leaders and 4 small fly boxes. The straps are easily adjusted and the pack rides fairly high, close to the body and out of the way. Not for everyone but I like it a lot.

Frank





 

Joni

Well-known member
Messages
4,611
Reaction score
19
Frank, your chest pack is the same one that comes with the Fanny pack Combo I have, except it doesn't have that nice mesh back. Just a strap.
They also have a belt loop for those spring creeks. NICE
 

Kai

Well-known member
Messages
117
Reaction score
0
I own several chest packs and several vests.

For backcountry trips where I'm covering a lot of miles and weight is at a premium, I just take a fishing shirt with lots of pockets, and a William Joseph Ultralight chest pack (only 5 ounces.)

William Joseph Ultra Light Chest Pack


For day trips or backcountry fishing trips where I'm not sawing the handle off of my toothbrush to save weight, my go to "vest" is a fishing pack, specifically the LL Bean "Rapid River" pack.

Rapid River Vest Pack: Fishing Vests at L.L.Bean


Why I like it:

1) Hydration:
It is the only vest/chest pack I've found that will hold a hydration bladder full of water. Other vests and chest packs are supposedly designed to hold a water bladder, but I've found that when you are wearing them, the weight of the water causes the vest/pack to droop down in back and ride up in the front, causing discomfort and a poorly fitting pack. (The William Joseph Fusion vest has this issue, in spite of the fact that it is touted as designed for a hydration bladder."

2) Waist Belt:
The waist belt gets the weight off of your shoulders, and also gives great support for your lower back when you are on the river all day. Some folks wear a separate lumbar belt for back support. It's not necessary when wearing this pack.

3) Accessory sleeves:
Every vest or pack these days has retractable "zingers" or bungies or the like to hold your nippers and hemostats. However, very few vests of packs have little sleeves to insert the tools into to keep them from flopping around. The LL Bean pack has both the zingers, and also some nice little sewn sleeves that keep the tools secured when not in use. They are immediately accessible, but don't flop around when wading.

4) Good pockets:
Fly box pockets are big enough to hold 2 regular fly boxes or one of the monster boxes. There's enough storage elsewhere to keep floatant, tippet, strike indicators, etc. close at hand.

5) Expandable storage:
There is an expanding rear pocket that can get big enough to store rain gear lunch, etc.

6) Price:
At $99, it's a bargain, considering what you get.

My only discontent with this pack is that there is no built in fleece patch for drying flies.
 

BigCliff

Well-known member
Messages
4,312
Reaction score
18
Location
South Texas
I like vests, but they're usually too hot for where I live, and mine isn't set up very well for hydration needs. I've got a Patagonia Reinvest that I like very well, and hope to need more often someday when I live where its cooler and trout run wild.

I've also got a really nice Willy-Joe "gear bag chest", but it gets a touch warm as well. I've gotten to where I use my fanny pack 90+% of the time. Its one Patagonia used to make that has a fairly large main compartment, a smaller front pocket with organizer slots, mesh water bottle pockets on the sides, and compression straps to keep it from bouncing around too much. A little looking around on the internet can find similar packs under $30. I recommend getting one that will hold up made by a high end gear co like The North Face, Gregory, Mountainsmith, Marmot, Lowe Alpine, or a similar company. Heres some: Campmor: Fanny Packs And some more: Lowe Alpine Double Dipper II Fannypack - Save 38%
 

makubwa

Well-known member
Messages
55
Reaction score
0
I use a cortland one - but most of the time just a small bag - depends on where I am fishing
 

Fish Bones

Well-known member
Messages
3,564
Reaction score
3
most of the time just a small bag
Yes... that little purple bag that comes with a bottle of Crown Royal works great. And its free if you don't count the money you spent for the beverage. :grin:
 

BigCliff

Well-known member
Messages
4,312
Reaction score
18
Location
South Texas
Yes... that little purple bag that comes with a bottle of Crown Royal works great. And its free if you don't count the money you spent for the beverage. :grin:

Sounds like somebody started their weekend early! Just kidding, and wish I could have beat you to it!
 

mojo

Well-known member
Messages
2,148
Reaction score
30
Location
Yewta
For me anyway is not a vest. I've found out over the years, I really like fanny pack type outfits. My problem with the vests, is, I tend to fill up ever pocket and the thing ends up weighing 25 lbs. I recently got from my lovely wife for Christmas a Fishpond Waterdance Guide pack. Very well built and thought out. It will hold 4 System X boxes easily. It also has a neck strap so you can use it like a chest pack. The thing that I like the best is the "fly desk". The front unzips and it has a large fly patch for drying or holding your flies.
Willie J products are great too and the new lineup competes with the Fishpond products. Both are priced reasonably.
 

Attachments

troutbum

Well-known member
Messages
130
Reaction score
0
I really do like the Filson strap vest's,but you do pay for them
Aaron
 

mikenewpal

Member
Messages
14
Reaction score
0
First, thank you to all of you that replied. Your imput has given me some really fine choices to look at. Man, do they make medication for this addiction or will I need to go to flyfishing rehab? I have fished and hunted continually since I was a kid, love it and live to get the opportunity to go...However, I never thought I would get addicted to anything else the way I am hooked on this new flyfishing craze of mine. Jeez, I am going to have to get another job just to pay for all my new found stuff! LOL

I personally like the look and function of the Clear Creek Elkader, Open Range Tech Pack, Rapid River, and the Orvis Pack that Frank has...In other words, just about all of them! They all look awesome! The Decisions, Decisions!


Thanks again for the info

Mike
 
Top