If you were me , what would you do ?

comeonavs

Well-known member
Messages
3,222
Reaction score
42
Location
Broomfield, Co
So, boo hoo poor me. Last week was my Birthday and between all my family I got a $650 gift card to my favorite fly shop. Pathetic part is I can't figure out what I want. Maybe I am missing something here you guys can point out. Options of things Ive thought of and reasons why I havent pulled the trigger

1) New Sage TXL-F 1wt.
I already have an Elkhorn 1WT I like just fine and only get to fish it 6 times a year or so cause of the wind. Is it worth plowing that kind of coin in to a rod that gets limited use and I have one

2) Replace either of my older TXL 3piece 3 or 4 wts with the new 4 piecers.Kind of dumb since both are still in great shape

3) 9' 3WT Zenith or One for nymphing. Problem is I have a 9' 4wt Zaxis and when I nymph I tend to run doubles with splitshot and strike indicators and I struggle throwing that set up on a 3wt.....can you say tangles galore from horsing it around

4) New waders, Simms G3 Convertibles. My problem with this is I have Simms Freestones that are 3 years old, maybe 50 days on them since I wet wade so much. MY Freestones got a little funky smelling but a gentle cycle in the washer took care of that.

5) I have Orvis backpacks, Simms vests and hip packs

6) Fly tying set up. This and the waders are leading the race but since I cant even draw a stick figure I am sure if I tied flies it would look like someone super glued boogers and yarn on a hook.


I have more reels than rods so cant even dream up something there other than replacing my old evolution 0 with a evo LT0.


I know , sucks to be me but I dont want to just pee away good money.


PS I have a good 6wt set up with a backup rod that never gets used since I fish so much smaller water.
 

Mnflyfish

Well-known member
Messages
646
Reaction score
7
Location
SE Minnesota
well since you have more reels than rods, I would go for a rod to hang on one of them. Just my 2 cents. Not much help though i know.
 

siskiyoublues

Well-known member
Messages
340
Reaction score
6
Location
FarNor-Cal
I'd be a charitable fellow and help this guy replace the 5wt he broke.

First world problems for sure. :D


Does the gift card expire? If it doesn't I'd save it until the waders start leaking.
 

biggie_robs

Well-known member
Messages
607
Reaction score
6
Location
Holliston, MA, USA
It doesn't sound like you have a rod you want and need, so I say go with a nice fly tying setup + materials. You can do it, regardless of your drawing ability, and it will increase your enjoyment when out fishing.
 

jaybo41

Well-known member
Messages
3,358
Reaction score
90
Location
On a trout stream/Suburban Pittsburgh
Nice conundrum to have. Happy belated birthday!

If it were me, I'd just sit on it for a while and give it a lot of thought. Assuming of course the gift certificate doesn't expire. The IFTD show isn't that far off (Aug 16-18) and who knows what's coming for next year. Then there's the closeout options that will come once the new stuff is released. Not sure if you saw my post in the Rod forum, but Sage has a soft action rod to be released soon--the Circa.

Sounds like you are more than covered on rods though. That Z is an incredible rod and when you're fishing a stream that calls for a 9ft rod you have a great one. If I recall, the bulk of your fishing is on those TXL's which are nice little rods in their own right. If you aren't wearing waders that much, I'd stick with the ones you have until they leak. If you wore them more often than not when you fish then a new set makes a lot of sense.

As for tying...it is a slippery slope if you are into it, but it's not for everyone. You could easily drop all that coin on a vise, tools, materials, etc. If you are on the fence, you could always get a cheap or used setup to see if it's something you'd stick with. I do it and it's a great way to kill time when you can't fish for whatever reason. Again not for everyone. It takes time, patience and LOTS of practice to get good. Classes and Youtube can cut down your learning curve tremendously.

Let us know what you decide.
 

coug

Well-known member
Messages
882
Reaction score
199
Location
Snake, Clearwater and tribs
Nice gift! You seem to have the trout weights covered, do you fish for steelhead? 7 or 8wt?

Does the shop offer tying lessons so you can try it before investing more dollars? Believe me, if you fall for it like I did then the $650 is like the first payment on a mortgage that never expires. I went off of the deep end and enjoy fly fishing much more, even though I thought that would never be possible.
 

williamhj

Well-known member
Messages
3,375
Reaction score
73
Location
Denver CO
x2 for the tying supplies. Has nothing to do with drawing! So much of it is learning thread and materials control and just following directions! Also take a good class. If you've not really tied before take the class first. It'll introduce you to the tools and materials and will help you get a better sense of what you're buying.

You mentioned having waders covered, do you have a good pair of wet wading shoes? Something for wet wading that works for hiking and is less clunky than wading boots.
 

ak allen

Well-known member
Messages
206
Reaction score
4
Location
North Pole, Alaska
What about a raft, belly boat or something like that? Or if there are any programs for teaching kids to fly fish, getting some equipment to donate to that.
 

wjc

Well-known member
Messages
2,250
Reaction score
71
Location
south florida
What about a raft, belly boat or something like that?
That's a good thought! Or a float tube if you fish ponds.

You also don't have to be good at fly tying to catch fish on the flies you tie. I've tied off and on since I was a kid, though all my flies have looked like a kid tied them, and no one would ever buy one if in a store.

Nonetheless, a number of them turned out to be better fish catchers than the many sto bought ones in my box. I bought a new vise myself a few months ago and have started catching fish on my own flies again after a lot of years of paying big bucks for ones tied on hooks I don't like. It all starts out with an idea.
 

comeonavs

Well-known member
Messages
3,222
Reaction score
42
Location
Broomfield, Co
Thanks everyone,

Jaybo you are right I fish those TXL's 90% of the time and 4months ago I added a ZXL for dry flies. So yeah you are right probably not many rods needed.

Other suggestions are great, Mosca the guided trip would be great but my Mother in Law bought my Brother in Law and I a guided trip for Christmas and we are going to use it soon.


One of my friends knows a guy who ties and has tons of equipment so I will go to his house and try a few shots at tying a fly. The shop the gift card came from does tying classes but not until fall/winter.


Since the gift card doesnt expire I will keep my options open
 

tbblom

Well-known member
Messages
1,023
Reaction score
28
Location
Myrtle Grove, NC
Belly boat and flippers, new waders, 9-10' 7wt for belly boat fishing.

or

10' 3wt czech rig and new waders.

or

peak tying vise, new waders, and a TFO rod.

or

a nice pontoon, or a cheap pontoon and a rod.

have fun! can't really go wrong with new toys :cool:
 

comeonavs

Well-known member
Messages
3,222
Reaction score
42
Location
Broomfield, Co
Thanks everbody for the suggestions.

The 7 or 8 weight rods would be great, but I cant see needing those inside the next 3 years. Since I never get to big water, a 6wt I have had for 3 years I used once.

did I mention my flyfishing buddy is neighbors with a rep for some mid range waders and he got me a free pair. So maybe no need for the G3 waders (at least if he comes through)

The vise, and the TXL 1wt are creeping up the list, or maybe I will buy the 9' 3wt and sell one of the 7'6" 3wts I have


Maybe after I spend the next 3 days at 9500' elevation chasing brookies I will have an "aha" moment
 
Top