Spur of the Moment Trip, Mt.-Id.-Wy. Tips needed...

GrtLksMarlin

Well-known member
Messages
4,164
Reaction score
61
Location
Michigan
Hello All;

It looks like a friend and I will be flying out tomorrow landing in Bozeman for a quick week long trip to sling some feathers at fish. Our mission being, to take the noble life-time allowable accomplishment of a Trout Royal Slam (Brook, Rainbow, Brown, Cutthroat, Golden, Bull, Lake), meant to celebrate a lifetime of fishing experience....and bring it down to our level of banging it out in one week :teef:

Why? Well if we fail that means we have to try again next year, clever huh. In any case what we're targeting out West will be the Golden, Bull, & Cutthroat, Laker a plus. The Cutthroat should be no issue. Our intent being, catch one/1/a single, then run like heck to try and get the next. However...

We're currently thinking one of Lightning/Golden Trout/Hidden lakes in Montana for the Golden, and due to current Bull restrictions in Mt., Bull in S.E. Idaho...For the laker we have no idea, yet push come to shove once we return to Michigan some of the local knuckleheads can put us on those on the big lakes.

Any suggestions for the Golden & Bull, heck even Cuts and Lakers out West would be appreciated....Thanks for any help!

B.E.F.
LCWCC-IGFA Liaison
 
Last edited:

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
Your best chance at bull trout this time of the year will be on the South Fork Flathead in the Bob Marshall Wilderness. The river headwaters in the wilderness and flows unimpeded to the N until it reaches Hungry Horse Dam. So everything above the damn is as it has always been: Bull Trout, Cutthroat, and mountain whitefish. You can target bulls there and catch quite a few. The challenge is getting there.

If you don't want to try to arrange a pack trip on short notice, you could go to the town of Columbia Falls where the dam in located and drive to the wilderness boundary then hike upstream as far as you want to. Also, on your back South you could stop at Flathead Lake and fish for Lakers, Flathead is the largest natural lake W of the Mississippi and unfortunately full of Lakers. Kill as many as you can.

I do not know of any Golden Trout lakes.

Sounds like a blast! Have fun!
 
B

blackbugger

Guest
Hidden and Golden trout lakes up Portal Creek are pretty easy hikes.
It's been years but they were pretty easy to catch back in the day.

It's not legal to specifically target bull trout anywhere in Montana except the South Fork of the Flathead which is a LONG haul from Bozeman. At least 7 hours, probably more like 8 or 9 though you can catch plenty of Westslope cutties up there as well.
You'd be better off on the N. Fork of the Clearwater, that's still about 6 hours from Bozeman.

Lakers near Bozeman? The only thing that comes to mind is Yellowstone lake but good luck on that one. Shoshone lake, Heart lake and Lewis lake have lake trout as well but It's going to take a boat or packing in a float tube and good luck getting deep enough, with a fly rod anyways.
Flathead lake is a long ways away. Elk Lake down by Red Rocks has some as well but fishing for lakers here would be kind of a waste of time given all the other awesome fishing available.
 

GrtLksMarlin

Well-known member
Messages
4,164
Reaction score
61
Location
Michigan
Thanks for the tips thus far....

As to Bulls anywhere except the Flathead being illegal to target, that's exactly why (due to the hike in) we're thinking Idaho. Some may call it a chump's call, yet frankly I ENJOY hunting and fishing by the rules. Though I can't speak as to out west, here in Michigan, our DNR really has made our state a tremendous sportsman's place to play. Besides the fact they know better then I, it's through those very rules and guidelines that our state really turned around with fish and game......So I'm a supporter of Wildlife Managers.

Any other tips as to Bulls in Idaho greatly appreciated.

B.E.F.
 
Last edited:

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
I didn't realize that you are coming from Michigan. In that case why do you want to try to catch Lakers and Brookies in Montana? They are both abundant and native to Michigan and an invasive species in Montana - in the case of lake trout, which have devastated the cutthroat populations in Flathead and Yellowstone Lakes or sort of a waste of time to find in Montana as they are small and inhabit only the upper most reaches of streams. Unless of course you wanted to find some lake dwelling Brookies like at Georgetown Lake, where they grow to good size.

I think it's honorable to follow the laws in place and not "chumpish" in any way. Plus this time of the year you will no luck targeting Bull Trout anyway except maybe in some special spots.

Good luck on the Idaho advice. Have you considered Alberta, Canada?
 

GrtLksMarlin

Well-known member
Messages
4,164
Reaction score
61
Location
Michigan
Thanks again dean_mt, blackbugger & SdDryFly...

@dean_mt; Well, the *plan* is to Golden first, Bull second, Cutthroats along the way (as who can resist walking by water with a rod in hand, the rest if we encounter them...However, the must haves for out West are the G/B/C....

Further, time starts with the first cast, and does not pause so we get 168 hours. Travel time is time lost. So we fly in late Thur., expect to be fishing late Friday, then fly out mid-afternoon Wednesday and should make it to N. Mich. before dawn Thur.. So at best I expect 36 hours to nab whatever remains.....Naturally, fail on the G/B/C and the game is over.

The Brook, Brown, and Rainbow we can nab in a half day all on the same very little river I love to fish here in Michigan (Pine out of Oscoda off the AuSable)....In fact, a river run holdover Steelhead is not that surprising, and during the run Salmon are ridiculously thick.

The real fly in the ointment are the Lakers. Besides being down deep due to the time of year, in Michigan the place to catch them is in the big lakes. So worse comes to worse if we don't get one out West we'll need to jump on a boat and so then they'll have to be on heavy tackle. All 7 on the fly is our ideal goal....and yes, Spring is the ideal time to do this.

Simply put.....It's what dull witted over 50 types do when they're too cheap to buy Ferraris. Attempt things that would tax younger men, then claim failure was due to lack of Geritol in our prune juice.....So you have to try again next year. :thumbsup:

Thanks again!

B.E.F.

p.s....I think for the Bulls we'll try either the Clearwater per blackbugger or Salmon in Idaho....and I now get 18 hours to figure it all out. Maybe the plan is not so good afterall :faint::wink:
 
Last edited:

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
If you intend to fish Idaho water and have only a few days to get all these fish, you be better off flying into Missoula, Spokane or Boise.
 

jimbaker488

Well-known member
Messages
156
Reaction score
9
Location
Houston
If you intend to fish Idaho water and have only a few days to get all these fish, you be better off flying into Missoula, Spokane or Boise.
And don't forget, if you are packing much luggage including a rod case, you get 2 freebies on Southwest which is the only carrier I'm aware of which doesn't charge for either of the first 2 bags. And unfortunately Southwest doesn't serve Montana.
 

GrtLksMarlin

Well-known member
Messages
4,164
Reaction score
61
Location
Michigan
Bump for the follow up!

For the record, I have really struggled with posting a report of this trip due to how it all played out. In a nutshell it turns out the quick hatched plan and its intended execution was very sound, yet there was one major, constant, and debilitating snag which made the trip miserable.

Anyway, your alls help proved invaluable.....Here was the result (in brief as I need to restrain my combative urges).

Seven Species in Seven Days, How Hard can it be?

As it turns out, not that hard UNLESS you go with an incompatible partner.

First off what say I describe the team members.

BF: (yours truly), Prior to this had worked for no less than 100-140hrs/week, every week, for roughly 3 years, and for not that much revenue for that matter helping a couple friends rebuild their business after the recent crash. Besides rarely sleeping, I rarely eat due to my wife's penchant for Pizza..........Top it all off I've pretty much lived a playboys lifestyle always having oddly had a thing for the gals, chain smoke, drink moderately, and wherein till 49 lack of excercise never bothered me even still lean and ripped, almost overnight I acquired the body of a potato with toothpics for arms and legs, lungs gone, muscles gone, and generally falling apart.

I had 3 actual goals on this trip......Get the Royal Slam, sleep/relax as much as possible, eat well......IOW, turn my life around and start getting healthy.

DM: Discretion restricts me from saying much. Lets just say DM is a great guy, will break his back for you, no request made of him too great. Top it all off he is extremely well off financially, and has gotten himself fairly healthy in all ways. That said DM is the cheapest person on the planet. Now I did not say frugal, I said cheap!

DM had a single goal this trip......To fish, period. Buster wants to fish and by gawd he will fish!

The Trip:
Unwise no doubt yet I had no reason to not trust him, wherein I did all of the planning and research DM had two sole tasks before the trip. 1. set up the air travel per our needs. 2. Arrange for a vehicle per my requirements......Did I mention he is CHEAP?

Working until the last 5 minutes before our trip, we race off to the airport oddly late in the day in my mind and against "the plan" quickly discovering that DM had used an appropriate travel site to book...."Cheap-O Air". Why, because it was the cheapest of course, and the cheapest tickets they offered would land us after 12 hours!!! in Bozeman at 11:30PM!

Naturally that entailed massive amounts of walking with all of our gear as we made connections....Not surprisingly having to literally walk from one end of each major airport to the opposite end, and I healthy as I am was on the constant verge of a heart attack. Of course I can get no rest, and to top it all off wouldn't you know it, we're getting in so late everywhere I can't get anything to eat.

Never the less we reach Bozeman on time, the airport all but closed, no way to get our vehicle, no access to vending machines, and this is me, pissed off, starving, exhausted, and holding onto anything just so my fists don't ball up....I'm the grumpy one on the right:


Having already had enough, I then step outside to cool off and have a smoke.....My God, cool but comfortable, the air so shockingly clean and sweet with even my dead palette I notice the vast and shocking difference. So much so though a chain smoker, it takes me 15 minutes to light up, and instantly I don't want it.

Montana is going to save me!......DM however had other plans.

DM gets a new job. His new job while I'm outside is to find us a room in Bozeman and get us a taxi there. A half hour later with no rooms to be found, and no luck calling a taxi, I decide to start asking around as he just looks at me and finally talk a driver into hauling our asses around as he graciously makes a few calls with all of the hotels full......or more, not wanting to book anyone so late as it turned out.

By 1:30AM we're booked into the Holiday Inn on the West side of Bozeman, naturally we get to haul all of the gear to the far end of the building, and more pissed off than ever I decide I need a drink, a smoke, and something to eat. Well, the smoke easy, the drink I find at the bar next door which oddly is also a casino (more on that later), and the ONLY food to be found is a hotdog at the gas station that had clearly been cooking for 11 months....So I had one bite of the dog, threw the rest out, and decided "tomorrow will be a better day".

I'll stop there for the moment...I'll post the balance when I have more time.....and yes, we eventually fish.

B.E.F.
 

GrtLksMarlin

Well-known member
Messages
4,164
Reaction score
61
Location
Michigan
New Hope to Gallatin:

So by 2:00AM I’m finally able to get the well earned sleep I have been seeking so long. Oh wait, that’s 2:00AM Bozeman time, my mind and body are still on Michigan time it actually now 5:00AM and guess what? Being the workaholic I have been, by 3:00AM BZN time I think it’s 6:00AM so time to get up and work.
 
When back home in such circumstances I’ll just stay up, so that nets me a lot of 24/48/72 hour work days for me, yet having intentionally designed this trip so I can’t work, I decide to go down to the hotel PC and firm up our plans. Unfortunately the hotel PC is all messed up. So after spending a couple hours getting it cleaned up, organized and working, I suddenly realize what I’m doing and say "forget this" (well kinda), and go back up to force myself to sleep though end up just tossing and turning till 7:00AM BZN time.
 
As the sun rose to say new hope sprung is not an exaggeration. Instantly I notice above our beds are a pair of beautiful paintings. One of a Moose by a river the second a Grizzly, and instantly I’m hit with thoughts of my Dogs (RIP) Moose & Kodiak. This is a good sign, an omen of great things to come! Outside to have a smoke I’m met with a beautiful landscape and a perfect morning, and it became clear top me that I needed this, I earned it, and this trip though it had started rough was about to turn around.
 
Unable to pick up our vehicle till 10:00AM (thanks DM & Cheap-O-Air), in short order the "fantastic and helpful" staff of the Holiday Inn set us up with their shuttle to be utilized as we need, and point us in the direction of Bozeman for breakfast, and the day is simply getting better by the second.
 
Once downtown dropped off and directed to "Main Street Over-Easy" a breakfast restaurant, I was instantly taken by how clean Bozeman was. Most of all how un-crowded Friday morning there on Main there was virtually no traffic, calm and peaceful on an absolutely magnificent morning.
 
Main Street Over Easy sported not only a positive atmosphere yet friendly staff and a vast menu. Now I’m like most folks having my pet peeves. My Coffee MUST be spot on at Coney Islands and breakfast joints, MSOE did not disappoint, but suddenly I’m struck by something that makes me uneasy yet I can’t quite put my finger on. A full breakfast ordered for me, yet DM just wants toast, nothing more just toast and water.
 
As breakfast was brought to us, the world for me was becoming better and better…..Get the Bison Sausage it was magnificent. Still there was that nagging feeling though I just couldn’t place. DM naturally all to happy to try some of my sausage gravy on his toast, and as much sausage and bacon as I’ll spare, yet the meal and service was exceptional, and I know that would be the case even if I had not eaten in two days. IOW, don’t question it, eat there, I’ll stake my breakfast common-sewer reputation on it.
 
Finally with a full belly, we step outside to find the weather better than ever. Maps, I must have maps! Unfortunately the bookstore is closed, yet what isn’t is the fly shop Bozeman Angler. Nice enough though not a lot of help in answering questions about Goldens which surprised me (in fact I think the gal working didn’t even fish), yet after getting a bags worth of stuff off we head back down the street to the bookstore (all of this on the same street within a block).
 
Vargo’s Jazz City and Books unfortunately is not open yet, and when Francis Vargo and Jazz (his dog) greet us instantly he tosses her inside and asks us to hang out as he runs to the bank. Of course I’ll wait, a beautiful day and there in the window is book upon book, map upon map on Trout fishing the area. The other side having more eclectic offerings yet when I see the Robert Crumb coffee table book I know that I’m at the right place.
 
Again that uneasy feeling crawls up my spine as DM doesn’t want to wait, he wants to get fishing. Yet with no vehicle he has no choice so I blow it off and besides I must have maps, we need maps. All of his muttering about just simply winging it will not get us to where we need to go 1,700 miles from home in a place neither of us have ever been.
 
VJC&B is a classic college town book & jazz record store except for one thing. It is chock full of maps, vast rows of books on fly fishing, but for me it’s the maps, I MUST have them! Mr. Vargo and Jazz both welcoming and helpful simply heaped on more of a positive vibe to the morning….Don’t argue, just go there, and as I stated to Mr. Vargo in the letter I wrote him among others after my trip:
 
"…as I tell the tale of my fishing adventure to inspire others to experience what I myself have, know that you and your business will be included. Included to help those that follow find their way with charts, and to set their personal compass in a positive direction."
 
If Mr. Vargo was not welcoming enough while there one other patron dropped in. An elderly gentleman with a wide and genuine smile to match his bow tie, yet what struck me most was our conversation. Every word he uttered was clearly said to get me to tell more of "my little adventure to come." Even his replies stated in such a way to encourage me further. Truly one of the nicest introductory discussions I have had in years, the gentleman only offering up that his name was "Patrick."
 
Part of our discussion led by him inspired me to speak on the IGFA to which he only commented how his father had helped found it. Then onto the club I belong to and Michigan. Looking back now I can only smile at my own naivete as I boasted how "well Michigan has also had its share of fly fishing tradition, Earnest Hemingway even wrote about his time and fishing there". Patrick just smiled and nodded as though speaking to a child stating "yes, I’ve heard about that." Then instantly led me to speak on more of our club, the IGFA and Michigan.
 
Such a warm welcoming and genuine discussion with a stranger about my little adventure truly touched me. Imagine my blush when a week later returning to the store I was informed as to who he was. You figure it out, his own life an adventure on par with his father’s. My subsequent letter to him included the fly used to catch my first ever Golden along with my sentiments.
 
Maps in hand and three (including Jazz) new acquaintances made, calling for the shuttle we were suddenly approached on the street by a tall lanky yet friendly fellow. Having noted our Bozeman Angler bag along with the maps, I suddenly recognized him from the restaurant as one of their dishwashers, he clearly seeing us as the tourists we are and asked what we had purchased and what we planned on fishing for?
 
For a good ten minutes he stood there offering up tips and advice as to where to go, what to fish for and what they’d be biting on. Most importantly though upon asking his recommendations as to Cave Lake, Lightning Lake or Golden Trout Lake to catch Goldens, with a horrified look on his face as he scanned us up and down he stated in no uncertain terms, that though the first two were spectacular, we’d be best off fishing Golden Trout lake.
 
About that time our ride arrived and we said our good-byes, only finding out later he was none other than Erik Carr, the owner of Main Street Easy Over and S.W. Montana fishing fame. I have to admit however, I felt a little insulted by his shocked look and patronizing but done in a very kind way suggestion to fish GTL. I mean what did he think? That we’re weak citified noobs having no concept of the outdoors? In any case his advice proved priceless and infinitely wise.
 
With that we were off to the airport to finally get our vehicle. "By the way DM, which SUV did you pick?" I cringed at his response of "well I didn’t, we’re getting a sub-compact, the least expensive (cheapest) car they had" and again that feeling of foreboding washed over me yet still I couldn’t place it.
 
DM however could not best Montana however, the good omens and beautiful morning would not allow it. Instantly we’re met with a problem. The economy car DM had requested was not available (no doubt it had been lost so small). However, for the same price they would offer us if we would be so kind and willing to take it, a brand spanking new, just in that morning, Triple Black Ford F150 Crew Cab 4dr. 4x4 with every bell and whistle you could put on one.
 
Yes! The omens were true, DM cannot kill this trip as I had told him we MUST have a four wheel drive and we needed something big enough to spread out in. Walking out to the truck I’m met with another good omen for a great week to come. A statue there at the airport of a fly fisherman and his Lab reminding me once more of Moose and Kodiak fishing with me on the Pine in Michigan.
 

 
Racing to the hotel to get our things feeling vindicated DM however is not. Granted, it’s costing us nothing more yet I can tell his intention of struggling through with a lesser vehicle has hurt his pride, so instantly he starts in about "lets get our stuff and get fishing" it now already 11:00AM BZM. Again that uneasy feeling of dread like deja-vu and I know deep down I should know why but just can’t remember.
 
Grumpy or no we still need things. Bear Spray, Fishing Licenses, a rule book to check ourselves against and while we’re at it, more maps! Unfortunately the DNR office is slooooow. Ridiculously slow and its instantly clear that the three people ahead of us are going to take a good half hour to get done. Finally its our turn, we do the dance, and though friendly I make the mistake of asking for advice to which the woman there states "sure, XXXX is out back, he’ll be right in" as all of the other officers doing nothing just mill around and say nothing.
 
DM is having fits. He’s so angry at this point I have to tell him to just wait outside. Naturally, he won’t pay for Bear Spray for himself. So after a good hour finally we’re off, and as I frantically try and figure out the maps DM just wanting to drive and get fishing. At this point he is so worked up he is literally screaming at the Fire Trucks ahead, lights and sirens blaring to hurry up as they’re slowing him down. Naturally we’re not even sure of a direction yet but finally I figure it out, and a half hour of back-tracking and we’re finally on our way to go fish.

Finally at Four Corners just West of Bozeman we turn South toward Gallatin Gateway. As luck would have it from all of his yelling DM is now thirsty, and as we turn into a gas station there beside it is an Orvis Fly shop called Fins & Feathers and I go in to confirm our plan.
 
Though very nice, the young folks (late teens) running the shop are not quite as diplomatic as Erik Carr. At first looking horrified that I would suggest Cave or Lightning Lakes as they look me over, they then burst out laughing and once they calm one of them asks me if I intended on spending 3 days to fish either.
 
Well no, just a few hours. He then explaining to me that Cave Lake is a nine mile walk and a near vertical climb of 6,000’ (actually is 2,924 and only parts of very steep). Further, Though only a 7 mile walk, there is no trail to Lightning lake, we’d have to scale a mass of almost impenetrable blowdown deadfall, and besides the 7,000’ elevation change (actually around 3,000+), we would either have to rappel in from the top of one peak, or scale a near vertical 1,000’ loose rock face….Go to Golden Trout Lake, and as he checked his watch stated, and stay the night there.
 
Okay, well, naturally not thinking of my own physical limitations, it clearly just a time thing, off we go to GTL being the nearest anyway as DM continues to complain "he doesn’t care, he just wants to fish!" In a short drive however we finally reach the Gallatin Gateway, and instantly once more all is right with the world except that nagging feeling as the mountains ahead promise great things to come.
 


I promise, in the next post we're fishing hehe...with pics!

B.E.F.
 
Last edited:

GrtLksMarlin

Well-known member
Messages
4,164
Reaction score
61
Location
Michigan
Buster Wants to Fish our Golden Years:
 
As the Gallatin Range approached making our way down the road instantly my spirits rose ignoring all else. Though I’ll not post the thousands of photos I took clearly having clicked one off each mile, just take my word for it that coming from Southern Michigan it was a magnificent change. Well that and the fact the camera I had bought specifically for this trip turned out to be a piece of junk. Yet that I’ve already addressed in another thread.
 
(Note: to one and all never having been in this part of the country. Just as you always hear, no photo that I am capable of taking at least can demonstrate the beauty, imposing terrain, and the general magnificence of this region. You truly do need to see it for yourself as in my photos 10,000’ peaks look like foothills, fish look like the Coney Island White variety, and I’m actually much more handsome than the photos show).
 
Barely into the foothills just like the mountains before us my spirits and that anticipation right on the cusp of an adventure began to rise. Even DM exclaiming how beautiful it was, all up until the Gallatin River came into view. "There, there’s the river. Lets find a spot and pull over to fish."
 
Instantly I reminded DM that we had a plan. Seven species in seven days. To do that we had to get certain ones and what would be found in the Gallatin we would find everywhere. Arguing with DM however was like arguing with a toaster. You’d push the lever down explaining the logic, he’d pause for the longest time, sometimes clearly pouting, yet at the other extreme commenting on the beauty. However just when you’d least expect it he’d pop up with the expected retort.
 
"I don’t care, I just want to fish. What makes you say there are no Goldens in there?" Well if he had looked over a fraction of the couple hundred webpages, pdf’s and book lists I had sent to him he’d know, as instantly once again as my spirits still rising that all too nagging tingle that something was wrong crept over me, and then DM went and said it.
 
"Look, I don’t care, I just don’t want to drive around like we did Up-North. I just want to fish!" Just like that it hit me like a sledge hammer as I pointed to a pull off stating I wanted a smoke. DM all the while griping about "why don’t we just fish there?" That split second I remembered, in an instant my generous gift of a year before turned ugly instantly flooding back to me.
 

 
Almost a year to the day before I had offered DM a personal gift for his birthday as he had just turned 50. The gift being though buried with work literally working 3 days non-stop to then sleep for 3-4 hours then do it again week after week, I would take him to my personal, favorite and somewhat hidden Trout fishing spots up north of Oscoda. Three days of fishing like he had never experienced, at my expense. Three days of misery more like it.
 
Those same words. "I don’t care, I just want to fish, not drive around the whole time" I had to listen to over and over as he b****ed, griped and moaned. He wasn’t lying. While I would try to get him to this spot on this river, or to that on another, DM would shout "there stop", jumping out of the Jeep pole in hand, and literally start casting into a 1’ deep by 2’ wide drainage ditch happy as a clam.
 
When I could finally get him to those spots he’d ooooh and ahhhh at the scenery, be shocked by the vast numbers of respectable fish, yet past watching him fish ditch after ditch when we’d get to my spots he’d be off and gone. Some of them dangerous locations (hidden holes from a century ago the massive Jack Pine stumps having rotted away). So I spent my time hunting for him on the river, often to find him pissed off I was looking for him, though he’d be wandering through the brush to get to the car in the wrong direction. Quite a few times getting way out of range and lucky I found him a couple minutes more and he’d of been lost and out of earshot.
 
Then there was the food issue. DM will NOT pay for food. He’ll eat what you don’t off your plate, eat what you force him by ordering and paying for it, he’ll even pull it out of the trash or go hungry, but DM will not pay for food. (Naturally because it is so over priced though in fairness he is not trying to get anyone else to buy it). That means either sitting there eating while he is waiting or go hungry yourself.
 
Finally he would just want to go and go…No rest for the wicked or weary. All in all the trip was rough on many levels. A gift so no qualms about what it cost, ten times more costly in hours I had to make up, and since I had offered I just endured it. This trip however was mine, I needed this. I had been killing myself literally and this was my last chance before my well deserved retirement known as a heart attack.
 
Mustering my own rage yet trying to restrain myself I refuse to go anywhere but GTL’s, back in the truck and we head South. DM now pouting as I had firmly said "no", and soon enough his tactic of driving too fast past every turn-off so I’d give in really backfired as we found ourselves many miles south pulling into Big Sky. Check the maps and make him turn around (yes his griping increased), yet finally we found Portal Creek road and our destination was in our grasp…Kinda.
 

 
Up to 7,900’ we drove, the road nice enough at first yet soon proved without the ground clearance of the four wheel drive we would not have made it or would have at the least negotiated around many of them. (Know many of the rocks in the road protruded much more than the junk camera shows).
 

 
All the while the same thing. DM complaining that this was a waste of time, a wild goose chase wasting time driving around hoping there would be a path to some lake when we had a perfectly good river to fish down below.
 
Finally however we made it though instantly I come to a stark realization. First off, my new boots have not quite broken in enough and I know there is no way I can walk any distance in them. No problem, why I brought my old ones…However, the effort to change them alone has me gasping.
 
Now I don’t know about the rest of you old bastages, yet when I bend over to tie my shoes or trim my toenails it’s a hit or miss proposition as to weather I can hold my breath long enough before I pass out. Yes, the poor diet, lack of exercise and loss of testosterone has taken its toll. But just like everything else I have ever done that was difficult, every injury that had me virtually crippled, I just knew I could "will myself" to get better and do this.
 
That said just getting my gear ready already had me winded. To that end, I immediately knew that the extra 10 ounces of long johns would be too much to carry, yet naturally was not willing to give up the hundred pounds or so of worthless cr*p I carry in my vest. Okay, a slight exaggeration, somewhat. In any case, vest, net, jacket, small pack with hip boots, second pack with water and other junk all on my back and rod in my hand off we go up the trail to Golden Trout Lake.
 
We have roughly 3 miles to walk and just over a thousand feet to climb in that distance. Seriously, how hard can it be? At a fair walk I’ll do 3 miles in 45 minutes, speaking of which I realize it is now 4:30 BZN time. Well, though I’ll not post the numerous photos know the one below was shot looking dead ahead, much of it roughly give or take a 4 degree incline if you average it, or 2.25"/30"step.
 

 
It took me all of 3 minutes to have to stop gasping and wheezing the years of smoking really paying off. The third time I stopped I told DM just to go on, I’d get there when I got there. So off DM goes as I catch my breath. Within a half hour I’m praying for my retirement. To you that means R&R, to me that means I get to have that massive heart attack, "here I come lizabeth, this is the big one", but no, I’ve not lived a good life so I don’t get off so easy.
 
Roughly 30 minutes later I catch up to DM waiting and agitated. So I make it very clear, "go on ahead, do not wait for me, I will get there when I get there" and I don’t see him again the rest of the time. Soon after again I’m praying once more for retirement, and soon after that I start looking for a sheer cliff, one where I’ll fall a great distance not just tumble till broken and suffering, yet none are to be found.
 
With that, too prideful to quit, too stupid to not, I press on. Soon enough I learn that walking till absolute exhaustion is more detrimental than walking a short ways and stopping for a few. Short meaning like 10 paces. But on I go, I will do this if it kills me. Please kill me, something, anything, kill me now. Hell, I don’t care if a Bear eats me alive, just please let me die.
 
Finally there it is. The top of the mountain, nothing but sky behind the trees! Nope. At the top, the next rise is just far enough beyond that you can’t see it above the horizon of the first, and worst of all the incline increased significantly at each stage. By the top of the second rise I’m considering cutting my juggler with my nippers. But I say this has to be it, just this next one. Nope. At the third rise I have given up all hope. God knows I’ve been a little b*st*rd all my life and is punishing me for it, yet now I really can’t quit and I don’t care. If I go back down I’ll live, yet if I keep going I know I’m sure to finally keel over dead.
 
Having resolved myself to a fourth, fifth and sixth rise now hell-bent on this small mountain killing me just so DM will have to carry my body back down, at the top of the fourth I walk through a thinning dying landscape and find this.
 



 
I don’t know whether to laugh or cry…..So naturally what do I do in celebration? Well have a cigarette of course, duh?! If I was smart I would be laying on a beach in Bermuda being fanned and served rum. DM however is stunned. A hundred times healthier than myself he cannot believe that I made it even stating how he had considered turning back. When asked how long he had been waiting and why he wasn’t fishing he stated simply roughly 30-45 minutes, and I realize he’s not fishing because he is still recovering.
 
It was then that I checked my watch realizing it was already 7:30PM BZN. It had taken roughly 3 hours to walk that mere 3 miles. Past being soaked from a heavy sweat, muscles simply exhausted from lack of oxygen to them but not hurting, and still catching my breath in between puffs on my cigarette I turned and told DM to go fish while I took it all in.
 

 

 
I’ll say it again, the photographs do not do this place justice in either beauty or scale. In the photo above the collapsed sheer rock wall in the background rises 200’+. The peak just beyond it 1,000’, GTL placed at a modest 9,100’. Compared to photos of other "Alpine" lakes that I have seen GTL probably ranks rather low on the "wow factor", however to me it was absolutely magnificent.
 

 
The lake is actually much smaller than the photos seem to show. Enough room that quite a few folks could fish at the same time without getting in anyone’s way, but small enough to make it feel cozy and secluded. Off to the South end there is clearly what was a camping spot that folks have most likely used often. Dead across the lake to the West a small waterfall running off from what I suspect is a smaller spring fed lake just above.
 
https://maps.google.com/maps?q=boze...eman,+Gallatin+County,+Montana&gl=us&t=p&z=14
 
Most of all however looking out over this small bit of water were the countless rises taking place. There were fish there to be sure. The trick now just to catch them.
 
After roughly fifteen minutes of rest, and another fifteen of exploring to the South I figured since DM was already fishing I had better get at it. Taking off my boots tough enough. Struggling with the rest like my hip boots, vest, and to rig my rod all taking its toll as well as suddenly DM shouts he has a fish on, and for me to get over there so I can get a photo……In a mad rush I scramble leaving all I need except the camera. Out into the water I go, DM yelling all the while for me to hurry and instantly I discover a serious problem.
 
In Michigan the bottoms of streams and lakes it is dirt, gravel, and at worst silt and logs still there from years past. The logs slippery to be sure, yet past that it’s sure footing so rubber soled waders tend to be the norm. Under the water at GTL it is nothing but large flat pieces of stone, shale perhaps it all looking like some old mountain had collapsed in on itself forming a shallow depression. However, those flat rocks are oddly tippy and slippery.
 
How slippery? Well, if you took teflon, covered it in ice, then painted it with snot, and finally gooped on a thick layer of KY Jelly you’d start to get the idea. Instantly I’m slipping and sliding as I try to get to him. A wild youth having destroyed my knees, ankles, and back instantly coming back to me as what the walk up wouldn’t hurt, the unsteady and slippery surface below is intent on tearing apart….In any case, thirty seconds into my mad dash and he loses the fish. Naturally even though it was still 30’ from him it’s my fault, so angry with me now he’s back fishing as I struggle to just get my gear on.
 
Wading out slowly realizing now that I’m over my head in walking skills and not wanting to be over my head in water, finally I begin to cast to the fish rises. However, the large groups of rises seem to move the second I begin fishing for a bit (and I’m sure I wasn’t lining them) yet eventually they begin to strike with a new yet rather welcome problem.
 
The fish are literally attacking the small #18 BWO so ferociously that in every case they miss the fly. Seriously, their hits were so violent that I believe they were pushing it out of the way as they surged up, many even jumping clear out of the water.
 
They hit so often that they forced me to check my fly no less than 3 times thinking that perhaps I had a broken hook. Nope, they’re just that aggressive. So onto a #16 hoping that will help them tag it, and just as I begin to cast so the call goes out again. "Fish on! Quick don’t make me lose this one!" Another mad scramble my knees and ankles screaming. Yet there it was, DM’s first Golden Trout.
 



 
Able to get a couple photos before it slipped back into the water, back I go as I’ve discovered that each time I stay near DM moves off. Again the fish are hammering my fly so hard they keep missing it. It was ridiculous how aggressive they were, and just as I go to cast having finally figured it out….."Fish on, hurry get a picture!" So back I scramble again almost going swimming barely able to get a shot off before it slips from his hand and is gone.
 

 
Okay I’ve had enough, time for me to get one and just as I raise my rod watching the water to see where they are biting, the water suddenly goes dead calm, the bite in an instant over. Checking my watch there is no wonder why. It’s now 9:30PM BZN, and I’ve yet to get a fish on knowing that this will very likely be my last chance to catch a Golden Trout. Nothing, I cast and cast. Swap out flies, move, yet oddly I can still see rather clearly as it seems the twilight there lasted till quite late. Perhaps an hour into it, finally I have a bite.
 
Literally pound for pound that little Golden Trout fought harder than any other fish I’ve ever encountered. Wilder than any Marlin or Smallmouth, racing harder than any Wahoo or Pike. A number of times it jumped putting on a display that would put a Sailfish to shame, one time in fact close to 3’ for it’s perhaps 10". Finally I suppose realizing that it was caught that little trout had one last trick up his sleeve that I could tell was both intentional and deliberate.
 
Clearly not his first rodeo, that little trout raced toward me, passed me, and went under the one and only deadfall branch laying on the shore and into the water. Now I had called to DM that I had a fish on and to get over there with his camera. Instantly he took another cast, and each subsequent time I called he’d cast again till finally with a few expletives added on, he took one more cast and began a leisurely stroll toward me as I rushed to untangle the fish from the limb.
 
Just like that, the fish was gone having clearly not raced there to hide yet to do exactly what had happened. Such moments are a high/low thing. Low in the regard you didn’t catch it, high in that the fight was awesome, and more so hinted at more bites to come. But they didn’t come. No rises, no wakes, just another half hour of pointless casting till suddenly there was another violent attack to my fly, and that fish just like many others clearing the water very likely would have hit 18" and fat. Like many others as well missing it, and I never saw that trout rise again.
 
Roughly 11:00PM, I start casting again, and again, and again. I have killed myself to get up here already vowing to never come back the climb so hard on me, and round about 11:30 I’m seriously thinking about quitting. Never the less I fish on. Cast after cast nothing taking the fly though clearly there are bugs flitting around me and with each cast I’m more and more thinking "frick it. If I don’t catch a Golden it is pointless so then DM can fish any damn place he wants as it won’t matter then, that problem solved."
 
We all do it in such times of lean, and also times of fat yet that moment I did what many of you have done it now 12:15AM. "Five more casts and I’m done. Five, four, three, two, fish on!"
 
This one fights twice as hard as the first. This time I’m careful though neither horsing him nor giving him too little as I edge myself away from that one lone limb. He fought, jumped, pulled and ran. DM all but having quit himself deciding to draw near, and after perhaps a three minute fight, there he is, my first and only Golden.
 

 
Was it difficult the climb up, the lack of sleep for days, nothing to eat save that one breakfast, the lack of air in my lungs? Well scroll up to me in the airport, here I am that moment, pinched, gaunt and exhausted, but I have him, my Golden Trout checked off the list……and if you don’t think I said a prayer to God for those last five casts you’d be sorely mistaken.
 

 
Okay, that’s it we’re done. What was perhaps 95 degrees had turned to 40. Thankfully I had not brought my long johns having only used 3 flies and nothing else out of my vest. Perhaps if we had been on better terms that moment I might have considered cuddling with DM to not freeze, but this ain’t hell and it’s not that cold of a day.
 
More importantly two couples I suspect had wandered up there roughly arriving around 10:30 and had been poking around our things halfway around the lake. So we head back over and do a quick inventory, they’re setting up camp and already I can sense they’re not too comfortable with us being there either so DM and I decide to head back down, this the last shot as we left.
 

 
Without trying to brag I have stunning night vision. In fact with the full moon besides able to see shadows distinctly I’m still even able to make out some colors without a light. For me at night, even a moonless one only lit by stars let alone a full one like that night the world still looks rather clear. On a night like that one imagine looking through a modern night vision scope. So walking down for me without a flashlight is not a problem….UNLESS someone else insists on being close and using theirs.
 
Further, I’m rather fearless when it comes to the wilds. The critters, getting lost, having to survive has always to me felt like more of an adventure than anything. DM however is a VERY (and I mean that sincerely) courageous person. He is courageous in that though he does all of these sorts of things regularly, I think down deep it scares him yet he musters his courage at such times and many other sorts of times and always stands strong. So sincere kudos to him.
 
However, in that almost instantly something large though not a deer starts paralleling us, DM decides we should stay close, and because we’re close, I’m now blind from his flashlight. Instantly I had to get my digs in now forced to have to use a flashlight myself, "bet you wished you had bought that Bear Spray now, don’t ya?"
 
"No" DM replies as he fishes around in his vest, "I’m not wasting money on that stuff, I brought this instead" as he pulls out and holds high a "rape whistle". Now before you all start laughing let me stop you right there. Though some insist upon a gun, others Bear Spray, DM had opted for a rape whistle and as silly as you may think that was know for an absolute fact that it worked.
 
Not one time, not a single solitary one the entire while we were out West was DM ever raped by a Bear. So laugh all you want, they clearly work.
 
In any case now we’re going down and though you’d think it was easier, it could have been except for one thing. DM’s light is blinding me. Worse still, now that I’m blinded by his I have to use mine, and literally every third step at the least I’m getting hammered by the trail. Here you go to step down yet the ground not there and suddenly you find yourself dropping that inch or two jarring you badly.
 
My knees and ankles are already shot from the slippery rocks, but now along with continuing to pound them my hips and back are taking a beating from the hard jolts step after step. No matter what I tried I couldn’t correct it and by half way down my knees are so swollen I start having trouble walking. Crossing the creek that runs into Portal Creek and seeing the climb I have to make up I’ve had enough. So with that I tell DM to go on hoping I can get my vision back, yet also knowing the perhaps rather steep 50’ rise and slight incline after to the top is going to take me a while.
 
My vision never comes back that night, possibly in that once onto the incline DM is shining his light directly at me to help, yet as you can guess it blinds me. By perhaps 2:00AM we finally made it back to the truck, and even DM is hurting so badly from the hard jolts that we sat there a good 15 minutes debating on staying or going.
 
Both deciding that we will never, ever do that again, we slowly drive out rewarded by the nice surprise of a Moose of all things at roughly 7,000’. On North to Four Corners, and DM deciding that "he is not going to put in on a room for just a couple hours" finds us instead finding a dead end road just North of the intersection and we pull in to sleep the night in the truck….which is fortunately not a sub-compact.
 
Unfortunately however, besides the swarm of deer that keeps stomping around the truck, I’m hurting so incredibly badly from my toes to my neck that after a couple hours of tossing and turning I can’t take it anymore. Besides at roughly 5:00AM BZN it’s actually 8:00AM DTW time. I’m two hours late getting up. So what if I’ve not slept in days (by that time I suspect 4), there is no way I’ll be able to now, and all of my tossing and turning will really throw my back out.
 
With that I give DM a shove, "wake up and move over," and I limp around to the drivers side, get in, start the truck and begin to drive to Belgrade to turn onto the highway heading West to Butte and points beyond.
 
Bull Trout our next quarry, and in that Montana is restricted as to where, Idaho it shall be.
 
B.E.F.
 
Last edited:

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
You are a crazy man! I love it.

I know all too well that feeling of cresting hill after hill hoping and praying that it is the top...only to find the trail switch backing up and around again.

And coming from SW Michigan myself, and being a former smoker, that elevation makes hiking even flat ground difficult.

If you ever come back, without your buddy, I'll take you out if you will reciprocate and take me to your honey holes in Michigan.

Anyway...great story man!

...
 

wjl

Well-known member
Messages
815
Reaction score
6
Location
Eden, Utah
Keep us updated.
Highway 191 out of Bozeman I could drive all day every day and pictures don't do it justice.
 

noreaster

Well-known member
Messages
858
Reaction score
21
Location
Prince Edward Island, Canada
Great thread. The whistle is a good idea. At close proximity they hurt human ears. Imagine what animals with heightened hearing sensitivity would feel? Looks like you had the place to yourself. Really nice stuff.
 

dean_mt

Well-known member
Messages
4,739
Reaction score
83
Location
Western Montana
Great thread. The whistle is a good idea. At close proximity they hurt human ears. Imagine what animals with heightened hearing sensitivity would feel? Looks like you had the place to yourself. Really nice stuff.
Maybe if I saw a bear at a distance and scare it away, but stumbling onto a Grizzly in the dark of night the last thing I would want to do shock its senses and cause an instinctual reaction to attack. Think about what happens when you walk around a corner and someone, a 5 year old daughter comes to mind, screams BOOO! The instant reaction is to yell and stand on guard...not run. I'd rather blind the beast with pepper spray.
 

noreaster

Well-known member
Messages
858
Reaction score
21
Location
Prince Edward Island, Canada
Maybe if I saw a bear at a distance and scare it away, but stumbling onto a Grizzly in the dark of night the last thing I would want to do shock its senses and cause an instinctual reaction to attack. Think about what happens when you walk around a corner and someone, a 5 year old daughter comes to mind, screams BOOO! The instant reaction is to yell and stand on guard...not run. I'd rather blind the beast with pepper spray.
I don't have a lot of experience with bears, but what I do know is that in bear country, are we not suppose to make lots of loud noises or loud coughs or throat clearings to always announce our presence as we move through the wilderness? Making shocking surprise encounters unlikely? Even if one blew the whistle periodically it would most likely keep a wild animal moving along.

http://www.tricitynews.com/community/122534544.html?mobile=true

But what do I know? I live on an island. :)
 
Top