The North American Fly Fishing Forum

The North American Fly Fishing Forum (
-   Warmwater Fly Fishing (
-   -   plastic grubs? (

turbineblade 01-23-2013 10:38 AM

plastic grubs?
Hi -- I saw post about this on another forum and was wondering about using grubs on a fly rod.

I caught a lot of fish on them with spinning gear, and I would guess that the smaller ones are not too burdensome to cast on a 6-8 weight rod. Anyhow, I'm not having any problems catching fish on traditional flies...just thinking about trying out something new for kicks.

Anyone tried this? I personally have no moral objection to this -- just wondering what I could expect. If anyone HAS done this, what size did you use? 1/32, 1/64?

Thanks --

Rip Tide 01-23-2013 11:04 AM

Re: plastic grubs?
I've used the smallest sized Sluggos (they don't cast well) and have also cut the twister tails off of grubs to tie flies with..... but that was before you could buy them just for that purpose. :rolleyes:

itchmesir 01-23-2013 11:11 AM

Re: plastic grubs?
I use to tip flies with Power Maggot when the fishing was really slow.. would get those early deep lethargic pannies to hit more readily

bigjim5589 01-23-2013 11:15 AM

Re: plastic grubs?
I've tried about anything that can be tried with a fly rod, at one time or another. I've tried spoons, spinners & tiny jigs on a fly rod many times. ( You replied in my Spinner Fly thread!)

I also have no qualms about using such things, especially when I'm after panfish.

Those small grubs, like the 1 to 2" sizes can work very well, particularly if you're chasing various panfish species.

Get yourself some various packs of cheap straight eye, Aberdeen style hooks, and be sure to get some with different shank lengths to fit the grubs. I always liked the gold plated hooks. Even Aberdeen jig hooks can be used, but the other hooks are cheaper in price. Add some bead heads for weight, and tie in some soft hackle, or Flashabou as a collar, keep the shank bare, or add a thread base coated with Sally Hansens, then after the cement has dried, thread your grubs onto the hook. You can get all kinds of weight combinations with beads, including plastic or glass beads. If you use the grubs that are transparent, a thread base on the hook shank of a different color, such as the fluorescent colors can add a different look to them. Some of the fine micro braided mylars make a good base too, add some flash & help hold the grub on the shank better.

These are killer on panfish, and can be used with or without an indicator (float) if you wish. :D

pszy22 01-23-2013 11:58 AM

Re: plastic grubs?
I've been using plastics for panfishing thru the ice for the past several years and they work great. Actually better than live bait in most circumstances. There are alot of different brands and designs, here are a couple of links to give you an idea as to what they look like -

Ice Fishing Finesse Plastics - Home of 'The Whip'! The Original Soft Plastic Ice Fishing Tail

Probably about thirty years ago I used something similar on a fly rod for blue gills. It was a soft rubber grub on a unweighted hook. The secret was to cast it out, and let it slowly sink. You'd watch your leader and it would twitch when the fish took the grub. It was extremely effective. It worked great in still water down to about 6 or 7 feet, much deeper and it took too long for the grub to sink if the fish were located on the bottom.

caribe 01-23-2013 01:28 PM

Re: plastic grubs?
Twister tail type grubs can be extremely effective. I thread a 1-2 inch twister tail through a size 10 hook and have a great time catching gill, perch, crappie, and bass. The problem is keeping the twister tail grub on the hook. This problem can be solved by tying 2-3 barbs on the hook shank that will keep the twister tail in place. Using 20lb mono tying in a small peice of mono so that it is a a 45 degree angle pointing forward. A couple of these barbs will keep the twister tail on your hook. Add bead chain eyes (clouser style) or a bead head if you like. The barbs will allow you to replace the twister tail on site when your "fly" gets ripped up or if you want to change colors. I admit I do not these as much as I used to but for a begining fly fisherman I think the fish will hold on to the grub a little longer allowing a little more time to learn to set the hook. The rubber on the grubs does get heavy for 2-3 wt rods.

jedwards36 01-28-2013 07:42 PM

Re: plastic grubs?
Put a 1-2" grub on a short shanked hook, and use A SINKING TIP! biggest part is the SINKING TIP! its a great way to do it.

roadkill1948 02-03-2013 01:00 PM

Re: plastic grubs?
I use lots of grubs and swim baits. Two things 1) the twister tails add a lot of wind resistance and can lead to twisted tippets 2) I use instant glue to attach the baits to the hooks, makes a big difference.

bigjim5589 02-03-2013 01:16 PM

Re: plastic grubs?

I use lots of grubs and swim baits. Two things 1) the twister tails add a lot of wind resistance and can lead to twisted tippets 2) I use instant glue to attach the baits to the hooks, makes a big difference.
I don't use the swimbaits with a fly rod, specifically because of the issues you mention. IMO, they're better used with other tackle. The grubs not as big an issue.

Also, I do use glue (Pro's Soft Bait Glue) with bigger plastics & other tackle, but not with fly tackle. Glues are too messy & the small grubs get torn up fairly quickly. I like to be able to change the plastic fast and the glue hinders that.
Glues are a much better choice when fishing from a boat where you can set the bottle/tube well out of the way, and I fish from my Gheenoe more so when fishing for panfish. I would also probably end up gluing my fly line to my hand! :rolleyes:

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:17 PM.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.8.9
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, vBulletin Solutions, Inc.
Search Engine Optimisation provided by DragonByte SEO v2.0.40 (Pro) - vBulletin Mods & Addons Copyright © 2017 DragonByte Technologies Ltd.
2005-2017 The North American Fly Fishing Forum. All rights reserved.